Free Sample of a Distinction level Dissertation (Primary research)
HJU
MSc International Business Management
Examining the supply chain resilience in FMCG in the UK
Student Id- xxxxxxx
Acknowledgement
I would like to express my deepest thanks to ———— without his/her support it would not have been possible to complete this paper. The supervision helped me a lot in gaining deeper insights into my topic and the subject altogether. I would also like to thank my family members, my parents and my friends for their constant support throughout my journey of writing this paper.
Abstract
FMCG supply networks are dealing with hitherto unseen worldwide difficulties. The world economy is suffering greatly as a result of the recent Russia-Ukraine war; food prices have increased and FMCG sector of the UK supply lines have been severely disrupted. The COVID-19 epidemic put a great deal of strain on supply networks across several sectors prior to the war. Customer demand, price inflation, regulations, digital attacks, and climate change all act in tandem with these challenges to constantly assess the FMCG supply chains’ robustness. On the contrary, customers are still requesting lower costs, and competition drives up the need for further increases in productivity. Thus, the task facing businesses is to increase productivity simultaneously strengthening the resilience of their supply chains. By maintaining its targeted level of efficiency, a supply chain with resilience can continue to respond to the effects of an unforeseen disruptive incident. Meanwhile, innovations, quicker product development, larger output capability, and increases in general system performance are brought about by the advantages of scale and educational possibilities made possible by the expenditures in resilience. This paper attempts to characterize the primary vulnerabilities that influence FMCG supply chains, along with the methods that experts can employ to reduce and triumph over the consequences of these shortcomings, in considering current difficulties that FMCG supply chains encounter as well as their prospects for resilience. This study centers on three distinct forms of vulnerability, each of which represents one of the three primary flows—materials, information, and money—that define a supply chain. With a primary approach and qualitative data analysis process though the conduction of interview, the study develops a significant amount of data that enables it in gaining effective considerations.
Table of Contents
1.4 Research Aim and Objectives 9
1.7 Structure of the Dissertation 12
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW 13
2.2 FMCG sector and Supply chain 13
2.3 Significance of Supply Chain Resilience 15
2.4 The process of attaining Supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector of the United Kingdom 17
2.5 Supply chain resilience challenges of the FMCG sector in the UK 18
2.6 Benefits of the Use of digital technologies in Supply Chain resilience in the FMCG sector 21
2.7 Disadvantages of using digital technologies in Supply Chain resilience in the FMCG sector 23
2.8 Strategies to develop Supply Chain resilience using digital technologies in the FMCG sector 25
2.9 Dynamic Capability Theory 27
3.5.1 Sample and Sampling Method 34
3.5.2 Participants/Population 35
CHAPTER 4: FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS 40
4.3 Analysis of the Findings 48
4.3.1. Assessment of Supply Chain Resilience Challenges in the UK FMCG Sector 48
CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION 59
Appendix: Sample Interview Questionnaire 79
List of Figures
Figure 1.7.1: Structure of the Dissertation. 12
Figure 2.2.1: Components of FMCG supply chain. 13
Figure 2.3.1: Understanding the FMCG supply chain. 16
Figure 2.7.1: Disadvantages of implementing digital technology. 23
Figure 2.8.1: Strategies to implement digital technology in the FMCG supply chain of the UK.. 25
Figure 2.9.1: Dynamic Capability Theory. 27
Figure 4.3.1.1: The effects of Covid- 19 on supply chain management globally. 46
Figure 4.3.3.1: Strategies for building a resilient supply chain. 50
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
1.1 Research Background
In the UK, the supply chains for fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) encounter several obstacles as a result of customer and decision-maker interactions during physical distribution, production, wholesale, and retail. The FMCG business operations might benefit from implementing the Industry-based technology as a potential solution to these issues (Nozari, Szmelter-Jarosz and Ghahremani-Nahr, 2022). The enticing qualities of technologies can reinforce the digitization and automation of the FMCG supply chain. The requirement to manage large quantities, a variety of goods, strict deadlines, and fluctuating demand patterns while maintaining product quality, conformity, and cost-effectiveness along the supply chain is what makes FMCG logistics so challenging. The FMCG business climate is complicated, unpredictable, confusing, and volatile in emerging nations as a result of global economic depletion. FMCG companies have to address rising client demands for personalized products and meet the growing need for products that are both economically and environmentally sustainable in today’s uncertain business environment (Shakur et al., 2024).
Industries are being revolutionized by digital innovation, which also boosts competitiveness, sustainability, and resilience. Block chain, IoT systems, and machine learning algorithms allow for data analytics, real-time visibility, and quick response to market shifts. Robotic systems are appealing to FMCG companies because they are precise and repeatable. The capacity to promptly adapt to operational disturbances using adaptable contingency planning and forecasting, encompassing material procurement, logistics, and product and service delivery, is known as supply chain resilience. The UK’s present supply chain problems are caused by worldwide material shortages, labour shortages, and transportation delays that coincide with abrupt increases in demand, especially for consumer items and building supplies (Sodhi, Tang and Willenson, 2021). FMCG companies must take a multi-pronged approach to procurement, strive for variety in their transportation networks, improve inventory management, streamline procedures to reduce supply chain risk, and use supply chain technology to increase visibility and agility to create a robust supply chain. Due to the depletion of the global economy, FMCG logistics which are typified by high volumes, diversity of products, stringent deadlines, and variable demand are complicated and unpredictable. FMCG companies have to address rising consumer demands for personalized products as well as the growing market for items that are both economically and environmentally sound in this unpredictable industry (Tarai, 2020). Thanks to digital innovation, industry has become a feasible choice with substantial consequences for resilience, sustainability, and industrial competitiveness.
1.2 Problem Statement
Over the past years, the FMCG sector in the UK experienced a range of supply chain risks therefore; it has been a problem for the consistent availability and affordability of packaged goods (Končar et al., 2020). The consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic, unknown risks linked to Brexit, and other similar events have made people unveil the existing weaknesses of FMCG chains, which in turn calls for improvement of the resilience of the supply chains to external impacts.
COVID, political risk, and regulatory changes are important drivers in the FMCG supply chain since it shift the location and increase the variability of demand. When the pandemic first came out, it led to increased awareness of weaknesses and led to stock-outs and other problems with logistics (Ivanov and Dolgui, 2020). Conflicts and trade wars also affect the supply chains as they cause disruptions and scarcities (Christopher and Peck, 2004). There are regulatory changes, particularly those after Brexit and they bring in issues that slow down compliance and functioning. These occurrences demand supply chain flexibility armoured so that product access reflects customers’ expectations within such a dynamically sensitive market segment as the FMCG. However, while the FMCG sector plays a crucial role in the economy of the UK, as well as in the consumers’ quality of life, there is a scarcity of research focusing on the FMCG companies’ contingency measures regarding supply chain vulnerability, including the related operational tactics and systems (Madhavi and Wickramarachchi, 2021). Knowledge on such indicators will assist in the formulation of the current policies, and strategies, and also the development of the plans in the supply chain of this sector.
1.3 Research Rationale
There are several reasons why this research study on the supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector of the UK is being done (Madhavi and Wickramarachchi, 2021). Firstly, the FMCG sector is among the most important and largest sectors in the UK economy, and the stability and elaboration of the supply chain require enhancement to ensure the economy’s stability and further development. Consequently, the disturbances of supply chains in the FMCG sector can yield dire consequences on the access of a citizenry to basic products, functioning organizations, and society welfare. Secondly, the global incidences and issues impacting the FMCG industry in the recent past have brought to the foreground the significance of studying supply chain management strategies and practices that lead to more resilient supply chains (Neboh and Mbhele, 2021). From divulging the various risks that the FMCG industries endure to presenting the available measures of risk management, and assessing the performance benchmarks for the industry, this research study can prove beneficial for industry professionals, policymakers, and scholars. This research will help address some of these challenges in the FMCG supply chain improve supply chain competitiveness and sustainability for the UK businesses and reduce the impact of disruption on the environment (Končar et al., 2020).
1.4 Research Aim and Objectives
Aim
The purpose of the study is to roadmap for examining supply chain resilience using digital technologies in the UK’s fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) sector,
Objectives
- To assess the supply chain resilience challenges of the FMCG sector in the UK.
- To explore the benefits and challenges of the use of digital technologies in SC resilience in the FMCG sector in the UK
- To develop a roadmap for managing SC resilience using digital technologies in the FMCG sector in the UK
1.5 Research Questions
- What are the primary supply chain resilience challenges faced by the FMCG sector in the UK?
- How do digital technologies contribute to enhancing supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector in the UK, and what are the associated challenges?
- What strategies can be developed to manage supply chain resilience using digital technologies in the FMCG sector in the UK?
1.6 Significance and Scope
FMCG is relatively a very crucial business sector in the UK since it plays an important part and fulfils the needs of the economy (Shakur et al., 2024). It contributes significantly to the stability of economic development since interruptions may harm stability, create gaps, and change the prices or availability of various goods. FMCG experiences complexity and pressure at both operational and strategic levels; studying the cases of resilience in this sector might help devise better solutions to supply chain issues and cut waste and inefficiency. Optimising the supply chain of FMCG international products can help the firms located in the UK improve their competitiveness by offering quality FMCG products that meet consumer demands (Autere and Sandnes, 2023).
To successfully analyze the extent of security in the supply chain of the FMCG sector in the UK, it is essential to have a theoretical foundation that captures how digital tools can be properly integrated. Existing theories that shed light on the subject include the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), which gives a basic understanding of the way perceived ease of use of the technology along with the perceived usefulness of the technology influences the intentions of the stakeholders in the adoption of the technology (Sheel and Nath, 2020). UTAUT and its extended version, UTAUT2, conceptualise some of the factors like performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, and facilitating conditions that jointly determine the use of technology (Tamilmani et al. 2021). Furthermore, in the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB), there is a clear understanding of how attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioural control affect a person’s decisions and behaviour toward the adoption of a certain innovation.
Thus, this research aligns with the theoretical framework by combining TAM, UTAUT, UTAUT2, and TPB models, aiding in the identification of the factors influencing the adoption of digital technologies in the context of the FMCG supply chain (Van Droogenbroeck and Van Hove, 2021). In a practical perspective, the research provides a blueprint for leveraging and integrating digital technologies that can optimise supply chain readiness, given the fact that FMCG companies seek avenues on how best to implement and optimally deploy digital solutions for a resilient SCM of their products. It also guarantees that the study will be theoretically meaningful as well as significantly helpful when advising on the ways of strengthening the supply chain in a vital sector.
Facilitating the enhancement of can also help the sustainable development of the FMCG industry in terms of decreasing unwanted environmental consequences that often result from disruptions and encouraging greener practices (Neboh and Mbhele, 2021). This research study aims to give an empirical insight regarding the challenges and opportunity framing the supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector of the United Kingdom and will propose strategies that could help the sector to overcome such disruption and therefore make a positive impact on the economy and the society in general. Therefore, some of the major factors that are focused on in this research study are supply chain mapping and risks, potential and actual supply chain resilience, supply chain agility and interoperability, supply chain collaboration and coordination, regulatory and policy analysis, performance measures, and cross-network comparisons (Autere and Sandnes, 2023).
1.7 Structure of the Dissertation
Figure 1.7.1: Structure of the Dissertation
(Source: Self-created)
1.8 Summary
In summary, interactions between decision-makers and customers provide issues for the UK’s fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) supply chains. These problems may be solved by putting industry-based technologies like block chain, robotic systems, IoT platforms, and machine learning algorithms into practice. But threats to the business like Brexit and the COVID-19 epidemic underscore the need for increased resilience. This study examines supply chain resilience in the UK FMCG industry with an emphasis on rivalry, seasonal fluctuations, and market demand. It analyzes resilience, measures adoption hurdles, and looks at tactics employed by top companies. In addition to offering ways for overcoming disruptions and having a beneficial influence on society and the economy, the research intends to provide insights into possibilities and difficulties.
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
The “Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG)” sector is the most promising industry of the United Kingdom due to the presence of greater consumer demand and the presence of different world-class companies. New technology and consumers’ ever-changing demands are continuously upending the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods sector. Consumers want inventive things, which imply manufacturing a greater variety of products faster and in larger quantities. Spending by customers is also increasing in new areas, necessitating an extended supply chain. Throughout the chapter, the FMCG sector will be evaluated with a focus on the United Kingdom’s supply chain resilience. It will also focus on the challenges of the supply chain impacted by the pandemic, political upheaval, and many more. Nevertheless, the context of digital technology in the supply chain of FMCG will be evaluated with the help of current literature. Not only will that but the theory of supply chain also be developed to ensure the application of the subject in the literature.
2.2 FMCG sector and Supply chain
Figure 2.2.1: Components of FMCG supply chain
(Source: Self-developed using Smart-Art)
The global FMCG industry is anticipated to rise at an amazing 5.4% over 5 years and will exceed $15,361.8 billion before 2025, as reported by (Shakur et al., 2024). Fresh avenues develop significant possibilities for business. Furthermore, research from Statista indicates that ecommerce is growing faster each year than traditional “brick and mortar” businesses. It is expected that consumers’ desire for novel product offers, such as healthier and environmentally friendly solutions, will present new chances for FMCG firms. As per the views of (Elfawal et al., 2021), the expansion of the “fast-moving consumer goods” sector is being impacted by rising middle-class earnings and improved living conditions in the majority of the nation’s cities. Industries are now more productive thanks to established channels of distribution along with creative strategies. Their main products have helped them to outperform their rivals and thrive in the rapidly evolving consumer goods industry.
As per the views of Alfarsi et al., (2019), Supply chain management’s (SCM) objective is to use effective SCM to maximise advantages for customers along with preserving an edge over competitors. It’s an indication that supply chain management organisations are working hard to create and run their networks as profitably and efficiently as they can. The supply network including the information technologies necessary for its coordination encompasses all stages of the development of the goods, including acquisition, manufacture, distribution, and marketing. As mentioned in the study of Ozdemir et al., (2022), because of increased international rivalry and shorter lifespan for products, FMCG firms are facing severe pricing pressure. Through the use of sophisticated transportation solutions, businesses can more effectively handle this degree of competitiveness in the rapidly growing FMCG sector. Ranking sales professionals according to experience, abilities, preferences, and additional variables is one of its numerous advantages. Businesses may see an increase in revenue if individuals decide to dedicate greater amounts of time to their establishment compared to their commutes.
There is some importance of supply chain in the array of FMCG industry. This is mainly due to the relevance of it in the industry. As per the study of Aityassine et al., (2022), Businesses in the FMCG industry frequently face industry-specific difficulties, especially in the area of logistics management. Several of the challenges are short lead times, rising stock levels, proximity to vendors, accountability, and confidentiality. In the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods industry, the consequences of inadequate supply chain optimization might be so severe as to put competitiveness in jeopardy. Slow-moving inventory might soon turn into dead stock, which would result in an overall loss for the business. A broken cold room or other piece of equipment could bring down the whole supply chain. As per the views of Calvo et al., (2020), as a result, it is essential to optimise and streamline the distribution process as effectively as possible, therefore innovation is always needed. Modern supply and inventory control strategies are frequently used as the outcome of the pursuit of increased efficiency.
2.3 Significance of Supply Chain Resilience
As per the views of Piprani et al., (2022), numerous reasons have contributed to the growing enthusiasm in SCRes. Businesses have been more susceptible to upheaval over the past decade due to the lengthening (more tiers), expansion (greater depth), and completing of their supply lines. In addition to being multifaceted, fortitude is a cross-disciplinary idea. It was developed from a range of disciplinary notions and conceptions that originated in science to clarify the ability of a substance to return to its original shape following any kind of deformation. A growing area of study called supply chain management is driving businesses to address this issue if they want to succeed in the competitive marketplace about sustainability over time and competitiveness.
Numerous academics have noted that the competition nowadays revolves around supply networks rather than groups. According to Mubarik et al., (2021), information is seen as a crucial, not tangible commodity along with a major credible element that forms the cornerstone of consistent progress and a sustainable competitive edge. Even though knowledge management (KM) transforms data, expertise, and academic literature into enduring worth by identifying beneficial information for operations management alongside expanding the openness to and accessibility of lucrative understanding at an appropriate moment to the advantageous person, it includes respect within the dedication it gives to goods, operations, and people in general (Queiroz et al., 2022).
As per the views of Kazancoglu et al., (2022), optimising the combination and alignment of inventory, demand, and interactions to effectively and profitably fulfil customers is another definition of supply chain management (SCM) methods. According to recent research, businesses frequently utilise performance assessments or assessment of suppliers to pinpoint particular supplier weaknesses and create strategies to fix them. These initiatives might include site inspections, accreditation of the goods and procedures of the manufacturer, assessment of the manufacturer’s transportation, effectiveness, and cost-effectiveness, as well as target development. According to the views of Tarigan et al., (2021), “effectiveness and efficiency” have both been conceptualised as “crucial metrics for assessing the operation of supply chains.” “Cost-containment and performance reliability constructions” constitute two renowned measures. “Cost-containment indicators” include things such as increased disposal of assets, logistics expenses, “inventory-holding charges, and cost-in and outbound activities.” The “fulfilment of orders rate, turnover of inventory, precautionary inventory obsolescence, and the quantity of goods under claims for guarantee are only a few of the topics covered by reliability indicators” (Tarigan et al., 2021). This study examines the relationship between supply chain efficiency and output.
Figure 2.3.1: Understanding the FMCG supply chain
(Source: Self-developed using Smart-Art)
It is anticipated that an effective SCM deployment will improve the rapport between supplier’s upstream as well as downstream clients, raising client happiness and company efficiency in the process. SCM has been identified in the past as a major factor influencing corporate performance. Everyone knows that an important aspect of “competitive advantage may be obtained via efficient supply chain management.” Consequently, the aim of the SCM process is needed to connect the final consumers, the avenues of distribution, the manufacturing operations, and the purchasing activities in a method that exceeds client demands for service while doing so during a lower overall cost when compared to competitors. Sustainability ought to additionally be a priority for “supply chain management (SCM).” SCM frameworks, or lean manufacturing, resilient, and green techniques, help businesses become more profitable and resilient in an industry that is highly variable and demand-driven (Queiroz et al., 2022). Previous research has concentrated on several of these supply chain administration perspectives and viability.
2.4 The process of attaining Supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector of the United Kingdom
Making use of digital Transformation
Accepting the promise of state-of-the-art technology might be crucial to attain the possibility of developing a greater supply chain. The applications of “Artificial Intelligence, Internet of Things (IoT), along with advanced analytics” may deliver instantaneous or almost real-time monitoring and perspectives, enabling knowledgeable, quick decision-making (Albukhitan, 2020). Therefore, it is important to remember that using technology alone is not always the solution. The way a company uses, implements, and continuously reviews and upgrades its technologies is just as important with current technologies. It has been seen there are many instances that hinder the process of attaining supply chain agility that cannot be overlooked with technologies but need proper management and preparation for a resilient supply chain.
Awareness of the Geo-political situations
Geopolitical concerns and interruptions are another constant in today’s supply chain environment. For instance, amid the ongoing dispute between Russia and Ukraine, multinational corporations, such as FMCG companies, required to maintain an eye on political and international tensions since they affected supply chain connections and accessibility, which in turn affected the flow and cost of natural assets not just in the United Kingdom or European Union but also internationally (Tarigan et al., 2021). Worldwide supply chains are becoming much more complex due to geopolitical disturbances, such as trade disputes and territorial disputes. The efficacy and dependability of distribution networks may be significantly impacted by these difficulties, which frequently lead to abrupt alteration of trade regulations, variations in currency exchange rates, and alterations in bilateral ties (Khan, et al. 2020). Geopolitical conflicts, for instance, have had a significant impact on the logistics of semiconductors, illustrating how political considerations may aggravate pre-existing weaknesses in supply chains.
Not only the factors mentioned above are linked with attaining the process of supply chain, but, there are factors such as accurate inventory management, strategic planning for the scenario strategically along with building collaborative partnerships in the UK FMCG industry.
2.5 Supply chain resilience challenges of the FMCG sector in the UK
The context of Supply chain resilience can be considered as a Fundamental and multidimensional aspect that imposes greater focus in acting accurately in a specific time frame to remove any kind of challenges from the supply chain. As per the views of Núñez-Merino et al., (2020), this can be considered as the proactive precaution of the supply chain in developing rapid and effective actions that involve alteration in consumer demands along with different present demand trends associated with the concerned business. The resilience or agility of the supply chain continuously deals with the actual goal of continually adapting cost effectiveness without compromising quality and services. According to the study conducted by Creazza et al., (2022), being able to react quickly to shifts is not an indulgence in the rapidly changing environment of “fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG)”; rather, it is an imperative that may literally “create or destroy” an organisation. The flexibility of supply chains is essential to ongoing survival in the modern world; it may no longer be considered merely a catchphrase used in conferences. There are about three multifaceted problems that are now really creating issues for FMCG companies in the United Kingdom.
The never-ending challenge of Trade Rules and the uncertainty caused by Brexit
Following Brexit, a great number of businesses and enterprises, particularly FMCG companies, are grappling with ongoing uncertainty and changing trade laws. The exit of the United Kingdom from the “European Union (EU)” resulted in a convoluted and unsettling situation concerning the flow of commodities and services. For instance, to persist in dealing with the “member nations of the EU”, numerous FMCG businesses were required to set up additional customs processes, which resulted in inefficiencies and bureaucratic difficulties. As per the views of Queiroz et al., (2022), particular difficulties have arisen from the importation and exportation relations between the province of Northern Ireland as well as the remaining parts of the United Kingdom, including enforcement actions and border problems generating interruptions. The limitations on trade as well as persistent uncertainties impacting the supply chain environment necessitate constant attempts to react (Teece, 2018). Therefore, the flow of trade and businesses has gone under significant issues imposed by the applications of new rules and regulations. Following Brexit, the United Kingdom’s government is still cultivating trade links abroad, which highlights the necessity for an organisation to be agile and aware of its end-to-end supply chain.
Unexpected mishaps in the Supply Chain due to the unavoidable situation caused by the COVID-19 pandemic
Though the Covid-19 pandemic has not affected the world population and business recently, the impact of the worldwide lockdown cannot be overlooked due to its significance in global supply chains. Global supply chain exposures came into stark relief in a startlingly short amount of time due to the “COVID-19 outbreak.” The “Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG)” firms faced many obstacles (Munir et al. 2022). For instance, rising demand for specific items, such as “hand disinfectants and toilet paper”, resulted in manufacturing and delivery constraints. Employees in production, warehouses, and distribution were impacted internationally by prohibitions and social isolation techniques. Additional interruptions were brought about by the lack of truck operators and difficulties in the movement of products. Consequently, FMCG companies had to quickly adjust their production plans and distribution methods to deal with these unforeseen worldwide interruptions (Bryce et al. 2022). The durability of supply chains ought to be shaped by the lessons acquired from this catastrophe. The discussion over the sustainability of supply chains concerning the constraints and applicability of the conventional characteristics of robustness to tackle an unexpected, enormous disaster like the “corona virus pandemic.” These have been fuelled by the fact that this problem transcends the unpredictable factors of resilience. Furthermore, the significance of the concerned resource coordination in promoting or enhancing the adaptability of transportation channels throughout and following the COVID-19 outbreak has not been adequately addressed in the global supply chain preparedness throughout the pandemic.
Unexpected occurrences that interfere with the regular flow of supplies, products, amenities, and data via logistics and supply chain management are referred to as disruptions to the supply chain. Potential vulnerabilities and dire repercussions for “Operations and Supply Chain Management” are among the primary adverse consequences associated with the interruptions (Talwar, et al. 2021). Recalling the very disruptive crisis brought on by a protracted pandemic epidemic like COVID-19, the unfavourable outcomes may have an impact on Supply Chain Management and businesses worldwide, causing previously unseen interruptions to networks and repercussions. The COVID-19 interruptions presented significant problems for supply chain managers, particularly in terms of devising plans to mitigate the impact and provide workable solutions to bolster “operations and supply chain resilience.”
“Environmental, social and governance and Sustainability Commitments”: A Sustainable Shift
The FMCG distribution networks in the United Kingdom are significantly impacted by changing consumer tastes and governments’ increasing recognition of the importance for worldwide progress regarding environmental sustainability including commitment to the three pillars of sustainable businesses “social, governance, and environmental” norms. This shift to ecology encompasses a number of elements, such as ethical sourcing and packaging that is environmentally conscious (Alkaraan, et al. 2022). A growing number of businesses, particularly FMCG ones, are looking at different materials for packaging as attempts to lessen their total adverse impacts and greenhouse gas emissions in the environment.
As per the new trends the UK and worldwide consumers of the FMCG sector are looking for items that fulfil ethical origins, “brands” are assessing the networks of suppliers to make sure they adhere to ESG guidelines. Integrating these sustainability objectives alongside the implications they have on the bottom line and implied profitability is the difficult part. FMCG companies are looking into more environmentally friendly manufacturing techniques and are investigating ways to get renewable resources while keeping costs competitive (Sharma and Sharma, 2023). Nevertheless, it’s a difficult task that requires constant creativity and modification to achieve this equilibrium. The difficulties stem from a growing comprehension of the true extent of the environmental influence and how people may truly mitigate it. Add in constantly evolving technology to an already complicated situation. This requires careful balance and must be guided by a well-defined business and supply-chain approach.
2.6 Benefits of the Use of digital technologies in Supply Chain resilience in the FMCG sector
As per the views of Yang et al., (2021), organisations are investigating new methods to increase the resilience, flexibility, and long-term viability of their business activities to benefit the community and the natural world, as a consequence of the expansion of the rise of “digital supply chains.” The latest study indicates that the widespread adoption of information technology supply chain management strategies, compounded with global unpredictability and swift technical advancements, has a significant impact on contemporary corporate operations. According to the views of Núñez-Merino et al., (2020), the main objective is to deepen the knowledge of the consequences for businesses facing increasingly severe supply chain disruptions along with providing actionable suggestions for building an increasingly resilient while advanced technological availability chain that will help secure an equitable future.
Manufacturing technology affects company effectiveness by lowering the level of greenhouse gases and consuming less manufacturing materials. Innovation helps the environment by lowering gas emissions and boosting productivity (Dubey et al. 2023). The goal of manufacturing methods is to reduce the quantity of inventory, and thus improve company competency. Finally, the adaptability and resilience of a company’s supply network influence its achievement. subsequently is still unclear how businesses can make sure supply chain operations remain ecologically sound and robust enough, especially in the event of unanticipated calamities.
Digital supply chain
In keeping with “digitalization, information technology (IT)” presents businesses with methods to create a lasting, profitable competitive edge in their supply networks by strengthening the links between particular assets, enabling more efficient exchanges of data, and creating longer-term, more comprehensive relationships, like those that the supply chain provides. Despite its unintended effects on “supply chain integration (SCI)”, “information technology (IT)” could potentially enhance the effectiveness of businesses by facilitating more effective and reduced manual data transfers (Khan et al., 2022; Aslam et al. 2020). A company’s digitalization may greatly increase its competitive edge. via this approach, businesses may be able to boost sales, and creativity, or explore cutting costs via operational effectiveness, all of which are advantageous to businesses. Nevertheless, there can be a lack of understanding regarding the direct impact of digitization on sustainable supply chains as a whole. Therefore, it would be advantageous for future research to investigate the ways in which technology may affect ethics, ecological sustainability, and financial sustainability.
Dynamism supply chains
The adoption of quick and radical modifications to merchandise and supply chain operations inside the constraints of technological and commercial situations is referred to as supply chain dynamism. A continual exchange of expertise is required because supply chain professionals working in an unpredictable setting must deal with a variety of issues that impede their productivity (Belhadi et al. 2024). Three parameters may be used to assess how dynamic supply networks are revenue generated services and goods, the pace at which processes are innovated, and the degree to which items are innovated. To gauge the vitality of businesses’ supply networks, an excessive amount of informal, non-standardized metrics and evaluation instruments are used. Creating thorough and generally recognized measuring instruments might aid in uniformity and encourage evidence-based assessments among different companies and industries, enabling the study of additional subtleties in supply chain operations methodologies (Attaran, 2020). There is a dearth of research on how technological innovation might manage and improve the dynamic nature of contemporary supply chain operations.
Sustainability of the supply chains
Using supply chain sustainability strategies is something that firms ought to undertake by expectations made by stakeholders and customers about “social, environmental, and economic results.” Both sides of an organisation, like the competitors, vendors, administrations, opposition groups, potentially customers, provide challenges (Zavala-Alcívar et al. 2020). As a result, firms should encourage employees’ capacity to adjust to changing circumstances. The definition of these competencies is “being able to satisfy the evolving requirements and demands of interested parties alongside the capacity to adjust to the global environment” (Attaran, 2020). The businesses must build the capacities and assets they need in order to take advantage of the changing market circumstances and successfully address the underlying factors driving change.
2.7 Disadvantages of using digital technologies in Supply Chain resilience in the FMCG sector
There are certain disadvantages or challenges associated with digital technologies application in the development of supply chain resilience (Ivanov and Dolgui, 2021). There are several concerns that are inevitable originating from technology tools combined with human variables, while the extent of these obstacles varies depending on the age of the sector.
Figure 2.7.1: Disadvantages of implementing digital technology
(Source: Self-developed using Smart-Art)
Challenges of change management
As supply chain management is undergoing numerous changes, it is necessary to build an understanding on the change management process. As per the views of Nozari et al., (2022), any transformation process requires significant management through the adaptation of corporate culture as well as team appropriation process. To assist employees with the technological transition, businesses need to implement effective communication strategies and implement true change management (Li et al. 2021). To ensure team encouragement and assistance shift is effective going forward, individuals must have access to the right materials. Therefore, digitising purchasing and streamlining and digitising the supply chain, in addition to potentially other company operations, provide a completely new avenue for value generation. Although a significant number of businesses were the ones to start this digital transformation, to fully benefit from it, businesses still must make adjustments to this fresh atmosphere.
Challenges of IoT Based Supply Chain
“IoT technologies and artificial intelligence” are two major areas of technology that are currently playing an essential part in the FMCG business sector of the United Kingdom. Innovation has taken on a major part in encouraging procedures to accelerate in an environment of varied activities (Khan et al. 2022). However, these developments confront difficulties just like any other new technology.
Cyber security issues in technology-based supply chain
A knowledgeable manufacturing facility, and by extension, an “intelligent supply chain”, is made up of both tangible and digital structures. The application of AI is used for data evaluation and generation, allowing for immediate communication while also raising the possibility of increased attack surface (Nozari et al., 2022). Weaknesses within such devices might subject the framework to attacks when several computers and gadgets linked to one or more networks are used in intelligent operations. Administrative system weaknesses as well as functional problems at the “machine level” need to be anticipated by businesses. Many businesses depend upon their computer systems and software suppliers to handle security issues that they are not necessarily equipped to handle in-house.
Absence of trust in digital technologies
At the fundamental stage of relationship building, trust is frequently present. The confidence of consumers is becoming more and more systematic in today’s informed, sophisticated world. A robust and sophisticated supply chain can require longer creating if digital technologies and the Internet of Things are not trusted (De Filippi et al. 2020). Nonetheless, a survey of research reveals that high dependability constitutes one of the fundamental characteristics of technology-based supply chain systems. Studies reveal that people’s mistrust and concerns about text-based machine learning on the Internet of Things are constant (Končar et al., 2020). Occasionally it is asserted that a digital technology system operates flawlessly in every setting, circumstance, and uncommon occurrence that it may encounter. Because of trust, evaluating dependability depends largely on having a thorough understanding of the setting and surroundings as well as the adaptability to deal with odd occurrences and facts. Such information is uncommon and rarely offers total freedom.
2.8 Strategies to develop Supply Chain resilience using digital technologies in the FMCG sector
Figure 2.8.1: Strategies to implement digital technology in the FMCG supply chain of the UK
(Source: Self-developed using Smart-Art)
After understanding the ways through which supply chain resiliency can be enhanced the strategies have been broken down into three strategies. Those three strategies have been included in the above picture which has been developed by using SMART ART.
Facilitating unified business by improving supply chain transparency.
Creating an effortless client experience through a variety of pathways, including online, at the store level, including hybrid approaches that mix both of them, constitutes one of the biggest issues confronting the FMCG business of the UK nowadays (Ivanov and Dolgui, 2021). Businesses have created an effortless client experience by using cutting-edge technology that lets consumers make purchases online, alert them when their items have been prepared, and identify when they are close. Implementing unified commerce requires insight into inventories throughout the whole network (Oriekhoe et al. 2024). Businesses can prevent stock outs and overstock scenarios through network-wide visibility of supplies, which lowers shipping expenses and improves overall client satisfaction. Businesses may make more informed decisions by using real-time insights about their supply chain, place of residence, and mobility through the use of modern tracking technology like IoT sensors and statistical analytics.
Working together to plan marketing and operations.
Leadership involvement from a wide variety of departments, including is necessary to execute effective business planning and marketing (Holloway, 2024). Luckily, this gets simpler as newer collaboration systems take the place of antiquated ones, offering a unified source for accurate data, user-friendly estimation, and effective dashboards throughout the FMCG industry of the UK (Shakur et al., 2024). When applied correctly, S&OP gives businesses the capacity to project demand and react quickly to shifts in market conditions. Additionally, by using this strategy, organisations may lessen the effects of financial developments along with supply chain interruptions through risk administration and preparedness for emergencies.
Using digital transformation to provide transparency and responsiveness
In addition to stimulating creativity, “regulatory and statistical analysis for predicting demand depends on AI and ML.” Instead of restricting the discussion to technological transformation alone, it ought to continue engaging in digital empowerment and company transformation since these developments have a tendency to promote consumer involvement and cooperation throughout the supply chain. Projection constitutes one of the innovations that 47% of FMCG businesses name as being prioritised for expenditure in 2024. These organisations feel that accurate forecasting consumption could boost their supply chain resiliency the most (Creazza et al., 2022).
2.9 Dynamic Capability Theory
Figure 2.9.1: Dynamic Capability Theory
(Source: Teece, 2018)
The “resource-based view (RBV)” serves as the foundation for dynamic capacity theory. According to RBV, businesses that possess assets that are exceptionally valuable, uncommon, hard to replicate and irreversible can gain an ongoing edge over their competitors (Nayal et al. 2022). These assets include individuals, assets, information, and creative assets, both intangible and physical. The RBV viewpoint concentrates on evaluating the competitive worth of a business’s distinctive assets and is built on the foundation of an immovable approach. The capacity of a business to combine, organise, and reorganise both its own and third-party assets and skills to quickly adjust to shifting outside factors is known as dynamic capabilities (Teece, 2018). It has been considered to improve the sector’s agility therefore is harder to duplicate than functional abilities. According to DCT, for businesses to obtain a competitive edge, they must not only have limited capabilities but also operate them well. A company that works in an extremely volatile setting needs to be adaptable to modify its flexibility in response to changes. It says that recognizing possibilities and dangers, taking advantage of possibilities, and maintaining competitiveness are examples of dynamic capacities.
According to the views of Teece, (2018), the advent of the COVID-19 pandemic in the United Kingdom intensifies the dynamic nature of the business environment, necessitating cooperation, integration, and reconfiguration of both inside and outside assets and skills to minimise interruptions. When unforeseen circumstances arise, SCR helps businesses to successfully identify risks before they happen and to promptly deploy their assets and ability to tackle them and resume normal operations (Wulandhari, et al. 2023). Businesses that bounce back fast have the opportunity to gain market share, hold onto current benefits or forge breakthroughs. The epidemic’s emergence has sped up businesses’ digital transformation. Supply chain operations employ digital technology to lower manufacturing costs and improve operational effectiveness. But these are basic skills that make use of current resources; therefore, they won’t help businesses stay effective in emerging markets.
2.10 Literature Gap
This research seeks to address the gaps that were noted in the literature review regarding supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector. Some earlier works have discussed more global strategies of resilience (Khan et al., 2022), while the literature on the application of advanced digital technologies in increasing the resilience of supply chains for FMCG companies has been limited (Lee et al., 2021). Moreover, insufficient investigation regarding the effects of some emerging global politics on the supply systems has been conducted, especially in the FMCG sector (Teece, 2018). This knowledge gap this research seeks to fill by exploring how these tools are deployed to create resilience and the impact of geopolitical tensions like Brexit as well as the Russia-Ukraine war on FMCG supply chains in the UK.
2.11 Summary
Taking everything into account, it can be stated that supply chain resilience is an imperative necessity for every company dealing with the FMCG sector; it is not a mere strategic decision. By utilising technology, fostering teamwork, improving inventory control, and planning ahead for any setbacks, FMCG firms may not only overcome their present difficulties but also set with that group to achieve a robust, flexible future. The crux of the issue is remaining flexible in a continuously changing environment and being prepared to change course when necessary. Being agile is a path to greatness, not only a choice.
CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction
This methodology concerns a predominant primary qualitative analysis to determine supply chain resilience in the FMCG industry in the UK. The study employs semi-structured interviews as the main data collection tool for select FMCG managers of leading FMCG firms (Queiroz et al. 2022). These interviews will attempt to identify participants’ knowledge, ideas, and approaches concerning supply chain disruption, risk, and preparedness. Due to its ability to provide detailed, non-numerical information, the study aims at establishing the problems experienced in the sector by focusing on the best practices and effective solutions that may improve value chain vulnerability in the UK FMCG industry.
3.2 Research philosophy
Interpretivism is the most appropriate research philosophy that can be used to study the resilience of the FMCG supply chain in the UK because, as has been observed, it assumes that the ‘reality’ of supply chain actors and their experiences are subjective and social. This philosophical approach agrees to the fact that reality is a social construct and that knowledge is constructed from the act of practice (Piprani et al. 2021). In the context of supply chain resilience, interpretivism makes it possible for the researcher to explore how the supply chain professionals’ view and experience challenges, disruption, and uncertain events.
This paper seeks to understand the experience of stakeholders who are significant to the supply chain of FMCG through applying an interpretivist paradigm (Shakur et al. 2024). This includes knowledge on their perceptions concerning the risks, decisions made and the course of action taken to improve the stability. Interpretivism is especially informative in this sense as it is more concerned about the context, recognizing that different organisations and supply chains have their particular issues that may be influenced by a range of internal and external factors. It does this in a way that enables an understanding of how different players in the FMCG area manage disruption to their supply chain and achieve resilience.
As a result, the research will be using semi structured interviews so as to get rich data from FMCG managers (Şababoğlu and Özden 2024). It will be possible to get a deeper understanding of the participants’ attitudes and opinions, thus exposing assumptions they make, and knowledge that underpins their behaviour. Thus, the analysis of these narratives becomes essential for the study to find out what general patterns and practices support supply chain resilience.
Also, its flexibility in the repeated development and interpretation of research results concerning qualitative data is helpful since it supports the cyclic approach in qualitative analysis. This also helps in tracking the fluctuating supply chain resilience because of changes in several risks and challenges as well. In sum, this work allowed applying the interpretivist philosophy that helped to investigate the human and social aspects of supply chain resilience in the UK FMCG sector and discuss possible ways of enhancing organisational preparedness for disruptions.
3.3 Research approach
A deductive research approach will also be relevant when exploring supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector in the UK since it aims to validate theories and frameworks relevant to a certain context (Bowers et al. 2024). This type of research starts with a general theory or hypothesis concerning supply chain resilience and then goes out in the field to gather data to either support or distinguish the hypotheses.
In the deductive approach to studying supply chain resilience, this step seeks to get theories and models from the existing supply chain management, risk management literature and resilience. For example, the elements comprising the supply chain resilience model can be used to generate hypotheses and are well defined as resilience, agility, flexibility, and redundancy are as well. These hypotheses might include such statements as “Companies from FMCG sector, having high level of supply chain flexibility, reveal higher level of resistance to disruptions”, or “The availability of diversified suppliers speaks about higher level of supply chain resilience of companies from the FMCG sector” (Ozdemir et al. 2022).
In a deductive research methodology data collection may use questionnaires, structured interviews or it may use secondary sources of data including reports in the industry, performance statistics and case-studies. Such methods make it possible for the researcher to collect empirical evidence from the population of FMCG companies so that the hypotheses are tested and conclusions made regarding the state of supply chain resilience in the UK.
Thus, following the deductive research paradigm, the goal of the study is to confirm the effectiveness of the existing theoretical constructs and determine concrete factors that boost resilience of the FMCG supply chain (Park et al. 2020). It offers a logical and systematic way to connect variables and analyse cause-and-effect relationships of not only the subject matter including supplier diversification, inventory management, and logistical flexibility, but also other aspects of the supply chain resilience.
Further, the deductive approach makes it easier to check the discrepancy between the real life findings and the expectation from the theories so as to enhance the understanding of how general principles of supply chain resilience may play out in real life scenarios. This approach can also bring attention to areas that current research theories may require further development or which may give rise to new theories, for the improvement of knowledge regarding supply chain resilience and for the benefit of practitioners within the industry.
3.4 Research design
When it comes to the research design, an exploratory study can be appropriate when the supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector in the UK is being investigated because this type of research is conducted in an environment where there are low levels of understanding of the relevant patterns and relationships (Neboh and Mbhele 2021). As supply chain relationships are most often very complex and constantly evolving, particularly in the context of the FMCG industry, an exploratory research design enables an open-ended examination of how these supply chains approach disruption, risk, and uncertainty.
As a result, the goal of an exploratory research design in this case is to determine the factors that affect supply chain responsiveness and to learn about the strategies that FMCG firms can use to improve their supply chain disruption coping mechanisms. This does not design research with a hypothesis that is expected to be tested but it aims at developing hypotheses as part of the investigation process. This is especially the case in operation in the FMCG/CG sector where disruptions may emanate from different factors such as natural disasters, political instabilities, or changes in demand patterns.
Techniques common in an exploratory research design are mostly descriptive and these include interviews, focus group discussion, and case studies (Akyıldız and Ahmed 2021). This enables the researchers to obtain extensive information from the professionals in the supply chain such as managers, executives, and the logistic personnel on their experience, perception, and implementation. Also, exploratory research might entail the use of archival data to find out new developments and trends on the given subject in the industry reports and market analysis.
Exploratory research design allows the changes in the research procedure as new data appear during the process (Casula et al. 2021). This is made possible by an iterative process thus allowing the study to improve and target on the probably more influential aspects of supply chain resiliency as this is realised. Thus, while pursuing this process, the research can reveal rather surprising findings, show some best practices in this field, and gain a better appreciation of the challenges associated with the building and sustenance of strong SCs in the FMCG sector. Lastly, through exploratory research design, it is sought to lay a general understanding that can be helpful for consecutive research studies and serve the practitioners to devise better strategies for supply chain resilience management. It is believed that through analysis of various factors and corresponding supply chain strategies, the results of this research can help to build more resilient supply chains in the UK FMCG industry in view of possible future challenges and disruptions.
3.5 Data collection
Data collection is also an essential aspect while studying about the supply chain responsiveness in the context of the FMCG sector of the United Kingdom (Munir et al. 2022). This includes collecting and analysing data which have been collected by other researchers, organisations or institutions in the course of their research. Primary data on the other hand is specific to the research topic and can help in identifying deficiencies in the existing state of supply chain resilience standard and real-life application.
When it comes to this research, sources can include industry reports, market research, government publications, journal articles, and white papers from consulting firms that operate in the supply chain management field. These sources typically provide measures on numerous dimensions of supply chain management including inventory status, lead time, supplier performance as well as the effects of disruptions. Furthermore, one can also obtain qualitative experience-based understanding from the cases and industries which illustrates typical supply chain issues and how the concerned organisation has managed them.
The advantages of data which are obtained from Primary research include the following. Rather, it is an effective method to obtain as much information as possible for a shorter amount of time, which allows building a more profound understanding of the general framework of supply chain resilience in the FMCG industry (Mohajan, 2020). It can also be used to make cross sectional comparisons in terms of time, space and company performance hence enabling the identification of trends. For example, studies of first hand experiences of the industry professionals on the performance of the SC over similar disruptions will be useful and highlight the different drivers that are strength of the supply chain, technology incorporation, or management of risks among others.
However, there is a need to take time and lay down criteria to assess the suitability of primary data sources. According to these contexts, researchers need to take into account the reliability of data, relevance of data, and the relevance of data in the context of given research objectives. This is why cross-checking data and triangulation is critical in order to avoid making the wrong conclusions based on inaccurate or outdated information.
3.5.1 Sample and Sampling Method
In choosing participants for this research, purposive sampling technique was used whereby only individuals possessing reasonable knowledge and familiarity with the topic under study: supply chain resilience in the UK FMCG industry were selected. In purposive sampling the sample is taken with the view of getting information on a subject matter that is under discussion. In this case, the target respondents that include managers, logistics and procurement officers involved in differing aspects of the FMCG supply chains were chosen to get systematic and particular information. This method enables the researcher to reach those people, who personally underwent through the issues and complexities of the FMCG supply chain. The use of purposive sampling guarantees that an essential comprehension of the aspect is engendered because participants involved in the analysis are purposively selected to give meaningful information (Campbell et al. 2020).
3.5.2 Participants/Population
The study engaged 10 subjects chosen based on their knowledge of the UK FMCG sector in the supply chain context. The participants were professionals in the SCF role such as supply chain managers, logistics coordinators, procurement officers, and risk management professionals practicing in FMCG firms. The roles granted them real-life exposure of dealing with supply chain management, and as such installed them with the needed knowledge as to how to integrate resilient strategies as well as risk mitigation measures and other functions in operation. The participants cut across multinational firm the FMCG companies and smaller firms within the region giving a general view of how the sector is immune to challenges. The research however sought to interview individuals from various positions within various organizations to ensure that it got a holistic approach to the issues that affect supply chain resilience within the FMCG industry.
3.6 Data analysis
The use of qualitative data analysis is an essential feature from exploratory analysis of supply chain resilience in the context of the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) industry in the UK. Focusing on the multifaceted and rich phenomenon of the practice of managing supply chains, this method examines the qualified experiences and attitudes of trade specialists (Ermes et al. 2022). Through the qualitative analysis, the researcher is able to gain an understanding of the disruptions that affect the FMCG industry, an understanding of how the companies Establishment react to these disruptions the various factors that make these industries more resilient and uncover new practices that make the supply chain much stronger.
The data for the current research have been collected through interviews that involve supply chain managers, executives and logistics from the FMCG sector with the use of predominantly self-administered questionnaires. These interviews are expected to provide a more elaborate understanding of the issues and prospectus relating to sustaining fairly robust supply chains. Besides quantitative data, focus groups and case studies could be applied to collect qualitative results with the aim to obtain the listeners’ opinions and present the results in the context of a particular organisational environment.
It has been described above how the analysis of qualitative data works in detail. First, the data have been transcribed in detail to have a clear idea of the content of the data (Allsop et al. 2022). Subsequently, dataanalysis have been utilised in order to identify themes and patterns of the study by portages in their response to research questions. Leveraging this approach involves text coding, in which certain segments of the entire written information are tagged depending their relevance to certain themes like risk management strategies, supplier management, the technology management, as well as leadership in resilience management.
It thus seeks to compare and contrast how different FMCG companies are managing supply chain resilience through thematic analysis. It aims at discovering the nature of organisational resilience and its determinants that consist of organisational culture, decision-making procedures and the outside environment. It also searches for the thematic patterns that might arise throughout the analysis process so that new data is being discovered.
Therefore, by emphasising the qualitative components of supply chain resilience, this kind of analysis can give detailed and substantive insights into all human and organisational factors that are so central to the management of supply chain disruptions. The conclusions made out of qualitative data could be used to define the set of recommendations, used in strategic planning and formulation of the policies increasing the overall supply chain readiness of the UK FMCG sector.
3.7 Research limitations
When analysing the findings of the proposed research that investigates the SCM resilience in the context of the FMCG sector of the UK, some limitations of the study should be noted. These may have an effect on the generality of the study, its scope, and depth in producing findings which are, therefore, qualified when read.
1. Limited Scope of Data Collection:
Collection of data is largely based on interviews conducted with the supply chain professionals (Jha et al. 2020). That is why this method provides rich information, however, it should be noted that the results can only be used to make conclusions and establish relations within the participants of the primary research, but not in the entire FMCG sector. The manner in which the participants for the interviews are chosen, normally through convenient sampling, introduces a bias that may not allow for the core views of different types of FMCG firms; from small firms to multinational firms to be ascertained.
2. Subjectivity and Bias:
An essential component of qualitative research is that there is often some level of subjectivity in the study from the participants and the researcher (Priya, 2021). The interviews could also contain social desirability bias because participants might give answers based on their experiences, their workplace culture or the wish to give their company a good image. Further, because of the researcher’s own bias, there is a possibility of bias when making interpretations and coming up with analysis and conclusions regarding the data collected.
3. Dynamic Nature of Supply Chains:
Supply chain resilience is a very fluid concept and can be impacted by external environment changes faster than an organisation’s ability to respond, among them being economic conditions, technological evolution, regulatory changes among other environment changes, geopolitical changes for instance (Pimenta et al. 2022). It is important to note that all data for this research work were obtained based on the current conditions that can be altered at some point in the future and thus the findings of the study may not have the same relevance in future. The failure to record the mentioned fluctuations may probably affect the study and limit it to the provision of long-term data.
4. Challenges in Measuring Resilience:
The concept of resilience is complex and has many facets; its measurement and quantification, therefore, presents a considerable methodological difficulty (Umunnakwe et al. 2021). Concerning the research proposal, factors that lead to resilience are quantitatively defined while methods that consider them are qualitative that could reduce quantitative analysis of the success that certain strategies would attract or the comparative analysis of resilience in two or more organisational structures.
5. Access to Data and Confidentiality Issues
Gathering actual supply chain information from the organisations under study may be difficult because of the issues of secrecy and rivalry (Hastig and Sodhi 2020). Some organisations may not be ready to disclose some information concerning their supply chain plans and weaknesses hence missing some data in the analysis.
6. Context-Specific Findings:
The research is based on the FMCG industry in the United Kingdom, and therefore the results could not be relevant to other industries of other countries (Tanudiharjo et al. 2021). In researching the case, it is well expressed that variation in sectors and countries results in different forms of supply chain challenges and/or constraints coupled with differences in the way the research is regulated in other countries.
However, the limitations highlighted in the study can be considered when discussing the findings of the study and the efficacy of the UK FMCG sector supply chains. These limitations should be acknowledged to inform future research directions and promote less biassed and more versatile investigations of supply chain vulnerability with the aim to improve supply chain risk management in various settings.
3.8 Ethical considerations
It is important to consider some ethical issues when discussing supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector in the UK (Carissimi et al. 2023). Firstly, participant’s consent sought from all of them, whereby they comprehend the aim and scope of the study, their contribution, and utilisation of their data. Based on this, participants bear in mind that they are free to participate and that they can withdraw at any time they wish to.
Participants have been assured that the information they disclose will not be disclosed to third parties or used to compromise a participant’s position in the supply chain as the strategies and threats are business critical. Data are being disguised, where it is necessary to exclude personal references that might provide information about the persons or companies involved in the study.
Finally, the research has no negative impact whereby no undesirable consequences should be brought to the participants or their organisations because of the study. Any data has been kept and processed with proper consideration and conformance to the laws and regulations of data protection as for example, GDPR of the United Kingdom.
3.9 Summary
This study analyses supply chain resilience in the UK FMCG industry employing the qualitative research strategy with emphasis on FMCG manager’s interview. It is important for identifying factors that may influence administrative tools that enhance resilience and organisational practices. The study also has constraints such as; It has less data coverage, It is subjective, and supply chains are evolutionary. From analysing the collected qualitative data, the study aims at offering understanding to FMCG organisations on how they manage disruptions, in order to strengthen supply chains, as well as offering a guideline on how resilience can be fortified in such an important industry.
CHAPTER 4: FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS
4.1 Introduction
The UK FMCG industry is adopting digital technologies including AI, IoT, Blockchain, and cloud computing to make the supply chains more resilient. These technologies help in proper dissemination of information and reduce the tendency for stockouts and overstocking. However, high upfront expenses, threat of cybersecurity, challenges over technology, and issues regarding data privacy are acting as the restraining forces for its adoption. It needs to overcome those obstacles by having a clear digital strategy, stakeholder engagement, connection with technology suppliers, and investment in training. The other issues that this business faces are logistics, regulatory compliance, environmental issues, and geopolitical conflicts. The integration of these technologies helps industries to meet market demand and manage the complexity of supply chains.
4.2 Interview Findings
Table 1: Interview Findings
Summary of the responses:
Interviewee 1
The UK FMCG industry faces supply chain resilience challenges due to demand volatility, external shocks like Brexit and COVID-19, and global supply network complexity (Du and Shepotylo, 2021). AI, IoT, Blockchain, and Cloud Computing are some of the digital technologies that might help manage such issues by ensuring less stockout and overstocking, along with assurance over efficient processing (Shobhana, 2024). Other ways of doing this might include investing in supply chain visibility tools, collaboration with the manufacturer, supplier, and retailer, and employing AI and data analytics for demand forecasting and inventory management. These technologies may further allow supply chains to become more resilient, efficient, and responsive-capable of withstanding shock and changing market conditions-by improving information exchange. Barriers to adoption of digital technologies include significant up-front costs, complex technical integrations, quality data issues, cybersecurity, over-dependence on technology, a shortage of adequate skills, changes management, cultural opposition, and non-digital collaborations (Yang, Fu and Zhang, 2021). Overcoming these challenges requires the development of relationships with technology providers, stakeholder engagement, investment in training, and a clear digital strategy by supply chain managers.
Interviewee 2
The UK FMCG industry faces significant supply chain resiliency challenges due to COVID-19, Brexit, consumer trends, supplier reliability risks, environmental sustainability needs, and technological integration issues (Odulaja et al., 2023). These may further lead to inefficiency, a lack of current information, and poor judgment. Digital technologies such as AI, blockchain, IoT devices, cloud, and RPA are being adopted for supply chain resilience. Supply chain resilience management strategies using digital technologies include the following: data-driven decision making, diversification of suppliers, agile supply chain design, training of staff, and collaboration (Bechtsis et al., 2021). Agile design permits firms to respond rather quickly in case of a change in demand or disruption to supply. Meanwhile, supplier diversity is based on reliance on a wider network of suppliers. Both require businesses to invest upfront in data-driven decision making via analytics tools. Training employees on digital tools can also support them in capitalising on opportunities.
Interviewee 3
The UK FMCG industry faces a lot of challenges in various resilience issues such as supply chain disruption, market volatility, sustainability challenges, and integration of technology (Kerekes and Adamsson, 2020). COVID-19, altered customer preference, reliable supplier, geopolitical factors, and sustainability-related issues are few of them. Supply chain resilience can be enhanced through digital technologies including AI, blockchain, cloud computing, IoT devices, and RPA. Supply chain resilience can be managed through various techniques using digital technology: data-driven decision-making, supplier diversity, agile supply chain design, staff training, and partnerships and cooperation. While supplier variety reduces dependency risk, data-driven decision making involves investment in analytics tools for the review of supply chain data. However, there have been several challenges, including huge upfront cost, aversion to change, cybersecurity risk, technical difficulty in integrating, and data privacy concerns. In sum, digital technology advances the supply chain of FMCG in the UK. The strategy needs to emerge as a balancing act between the accruing benefits from this and the risks involved.
Interviewee 4
The issues on resilience of the UK FMCG industry to address are the number of suppliers, being invisible, poorly communicating, vulnerable to cyberattacks, little standardization, and the continued dependence on manual processes. Blockchain, cloud-based platforms, IoT sensors, digital twins, and cybersecurity solutions are some of the digital technologies that can further improve supply chain resilience (Salmi, 2024). These various methods of handling resilience create a cloud-based visibility platform that includes IoT sensors, blockchain, and predictive analytics models. The benefits of digital technologies include visibility of increased supply, demand forecasting, agility, decision-making, supplier cooperation, automation, efficiency, customer happiness, cost reduction, improvement in regulatory compliance, recovery capability, and sustainability. Yet, high upfront costs, challenges of integration, perils of cyber, data quality issues, the gap in skills, management of change, sensitivity regarding culture and data privacy, and loss of jobs-each of them acts as a stumbling block to their implementation.
Interviewee 5
The transportation manager for the FMCG industry in the UK, a 55-year-old, pointed out supply chain vulnerability drivers such as driver shortage, fuel price volatility, traffic and weather, capacity constraints, unpredictable demand, supply chain visibility, cybersecurity threats, and worsening road infrastructure. All of these could be potential issues that may hit the whole resilience of the supply chain, probably impacting economics, efficiency, and dependability of the transport operations. It’s important to apply digital technologies like EDI, blockchain, digital twin, drones, autonomous cars, cloud-based platforms, GPS tracking, Internet of Things sensors, AI, and ML to improve supply chain resilience. Digital technologies like predictive analytics, machine learning, IoT sensors, blockchain, automation, robotics, control tower approach, and culture promotion are utilized to manage supply chain resilience (Ashfaq, 2022). However, these may be quite effectively hampered by challenges in high installation costs, integration issues, data integrity, cybersecurity, and cultural reluctance to change.
Interviewee 6
The UK FMCG industry faces supply chain resilience challenges due to demand volatility, external shocks like Brexit and COVID-19, and complex global supply networks with geopolitical tensions and trade laws (Hong and Zahid, 2023). It reduces stockouts and overstocking, and ensures efficient processing. Digital technologies like artificial intelligence, the Internet of Things, blockchain, and cloud computing can overcome these issues. Digital technologies like supply chain visibility tools, collaboration with manufacturers, suppliers, and retailers, and AI for demand forecasting and inventory management are crucial for supply chain resilience. These technologies can also render supply chains more responsive, efficient, and resilient-thus better able to absorb shocks and changing market conditions-through enhanced information sharing. On the other hand, though, its adoption may be discouraged through large upfront costs, challenging technological integrations, issues with data quality, concerns about cybersecurity, over-reliance on technology, lack of experience, change management, cultural resistance, and non-digital collaboration. These difficulties can be overcome if the supply chain managers create relationships with technology providers, involve stakeholders, invest in training, and have a clear digital strategy.
Interviewee 7
The UK’s FMCG supply chain faces challenges such as COVID-19, Brexit, consumer trends, supplier reliability risks, environmental sustainability needs, and technology integration issues. These may very well result in ineffectiveness, a lack of timely information, and impaired judgment. Digital technologies like AI, blockchain, IoT devices, the cloud, and RPA are enhancing supply chain resilience. These tactics involve data-driven decision-making, diversification of supplies, agile supply chain design, staff training, and cooperation as methods for managing supply chain resilience through digital technology. Agile design enables enterprises to swiftly adapt to demand or supply disruptions, manage large supplier networks, and maximize opportunities through employee training in digital tools. Analytics tools are required to be invested in as decisions need to be data-driven. A number of benefits of the digital technologies include efficiency, visibility, happier customers, and fewer risks. Automation and AI make the processes smoother, reducing operational costs and allowing access to data in real time (Haider Ali Javaid, 2024).
Interviewee 8
Supply chain discontinuity, market instability, sustainability issues, and technological integration are some of the many different aspects of challenges that surround the UK FMCG industry regarding resilience. Besides COVID-19, some of the other challenges include shifts in customer preference, reliable supplies, geopolitical factors, and sustainability (Fonseca and Azevedo, 2020). Digital technologies like AI, blockchain, cloud computing, IoT devices, and RPA make supply chains more resilient. Supply chain resilience can be controlled through several techniques using digital technology, such as data-driven decision making, supplier diversity, agile supply chain design, personnel training, and partnerships and collaboration. Digital technology contributes to customer satisfaction, efficiency, visibility, and attainment of sustainability criteria. There are several challenges, including high upfront cost, resistance to change, cybersecurity threat, integration challenge, and data privacy concern. Those businesses that have already begun to tap into the power of digital technologies pay a great deal of attention to resilience, deftly negotiate the complexities of the supply chain, and efficiently meet the demands of the market. These tools, when effectively integrated, can significantly improve operational capabilities and establish a strong reputation for responsiveness and reliability. Adaptability and creative problem-solving lie at the heart of long-term success in a UK FMCG environment characterised by unpredictability and rapid change (Sony and Mekoth, 2022).
Interviewee 9
Resilience challenges that the UK FMCG industry must cope with include a vast number of suppliers, hidden, poorly communicated, vulnerable to cyberattacks, with little standardisation, and relying extensively on manual processes. Some digital technologies capable of improving supply chain resilience are blockchain, IoT sensors, digital twins, and cybersecurity solutions. Other ways of managing resilience involve IoT sensors attached to products or pallets, development of a cloud-based supply chain visibility platform, block-chain technology, and predictive analytics models. Some benefits accrued through digital technologies are increased visibility, demand forecasting, agility in decision-making, coordination with suppliers, automation, efficiency, customer delight, cost reduction, adherence to regulatory requirements, recoverability, sustainability amongst others. These are high up-front costs, integration obstacles, cyber dangers, problems concerning data quality, skills gap, change management, cultural sensitivity, data privacy, and job losses. Digital technologies are vital in the development of a stronger supply chain, as the technologies offer a business vision, flexibility, and insight into a complex business world.
Interviewee 10
The 55-year-old Transportation Manager in the FMCG industry in the UK identifies supply chain vulnerabilities such as shortages of drivers, volatile fuel prices, traffic, weather, capacity limitations, unpredictable demand, supply chain visibility, cybersecurity threats, and deteriorating road infrastructure. Each one of these challenges may have an impact on the resilience of the whole supply chain and thus an impact on the economics, efficiency, and dependability of transport operations. Digital technologies such as EDI, blockchain, digital twins, drones, autonomous cars, cloud-based platforms, GPS tracking, Internet of Things sensors, AI, and ML help supply chain resilience (Pettit, Wang and Beresford, 2022). Supply chain resilience can be managed using blockchain, cloud-based platforms, IoT sensors, predictive analytics, robotics, automation, control tower approach, digital platforms, risk management, and innovation culture promotion. However, there are various issues that may hamper the deployment of digital technology, including high costs of setup, integration, data quality, cybersecurity, and cultural aversion to change.
4.3 Analysis of the Findings
4.3.1. Assessment of Supply Chain Resilience Challenges in the UK FMCG Sector
Figure 4.3.1.1: The effects of Covid- 19 on supply chain management globally
(Source: Chang, 2019)
The FMCG industry is quite an integral part of the UK economy, goods that are purchased quickly but tend to be fairly cheap. This consists of foodstuffs, beverages, toiletries, and other consumables. In 2021, the FMCG market in the UK was valued at approximately £173 billion, while the grocery segment accounted for a significant share of that valuation (admin_purestaff, 2023). The sector has high competition, low margins, and fast turnover, which adds to some peculiar challenges in supply chain management. FMCG is a very consumer-oriented sector that might change drastically due to trends, seasons, and even economic conditions. With the rise of e-commerce, especially the COVID-19 pandemic, which saw online grocery sales surge 113%, the landscape has continued to change (Galushko and Riabchyk, 2024). This continued growth is an indication that supply chains should be agile to meet altering consumer preferences. Probably one of the most dramatic challenges facing the FMCG sector, volatility of demand is one of the leading concerns. Trends, seasons, and unplanned events-like health crises-can vary tremendously in consumer tastes and preferences. A recent study by the BRC in 2022 found that the volatile habits of consumers through the pandemic have resulted in fluctuations in demand from FMCG companies in 75% of instances (Żurek et al., 2024).
It is these unforeseen changes in trends that make inventory management much more complex and result in overstocking or stockouts, thereby denting profitability or customer satisfaction. The inability to forecast demand precisely may lead to a wastage of resources. For instance, a report by Deloitte in 2021 estimated that inventory distortion-overstock or understock-costs UK retailers an estimated £1.1 billion yearly (Falatouri et al., 2022). This challenge requires more sophisticated forecasting methods and agile supply chain responses. The other important challenge relates to the reliability of suppliers. Very often, the FMCG sector depends on a network of suppliers for raw materials, packaging, and logistics. The disruptions in any part of the network would result in considerable delays and an increase in cost. According to a survey conducted by the Institute of Supply Chain Management, 67% of FMCG firms reported issues concerning the reliability of suppliers in the year 2022 on account of geopolitical tensions, trade barriers, and logistical bottlenecks (KPMG, 2023).
The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted pointedly how fragile supply chains are in this world. The closure of Asian factories affected the UK economy’s essential commodities availability, highlighting the vulnerability of interdependent supply chains to local interruptions. Companies should now consider diversification of their supplier base and closer relationships with key suppliers to diminish such risks. Logistics are very crucial in the FMCG sector, wherein timely delivery is absolutely essential. About 75% of all goods transported in the UK are moved via road freight transport; hence, the infrastructure remains highly utilised. However, more often than not, logistical disruptions have increased on a number of touchpoints, starting with traffic congestion and advancing through driver shortages to port delays. A shortage in the number of HGV drivers in the UK reached a bit of a crisis situation in 2021, with estimates being that there was a shortfall of about 100,000 drivers (Lavri, 2023). This directly impacted the ability of FMCG companies to deliver products in time, and the result was empty shelves and lost sales. Furthermore, the ongoing implications of Brexit have brought additional complications, such as customs delays and extra paperwork, exacerbating logistics challenges. The regulatory environment is continuously changing, thereby setting up a high level of impact on the sector of FMCG. Adhering to health and safety standards, environmental regulations, and labelling requirements is a drain on resources and complicates supply chains. For example, new regulations instituted following Brexit meant that FMCG businesses had to redefine supply chains in line with different trading standards now in place with the EU.
A 2022 survey by KPMG found that for 58% of FMCGs, the main priority of regulatory compliance-especially sustainability-is growing demand for green products (KPMG, 2022). Pressure to make sure supply chains deliver on this drives operations that are increasingly complex and costly. The UK’s economic climate-including inflation rates and changes in the spending power of consumers-continues to have a strong bearing on the sector. The COVID-19 pandemic revealed the weaknesses in supply chains, and geopolitics, such as what is currently happening in Ukraine, has resulted in rising energy prices that have impacted transportation and the stability of supply chains in general.
4.3.2 Exploring the Benefits and Challenges of Digital Technologies in Enhancing Supply Chain Resilience in the UK FMCG Sector
Figure 4.3.2.1: Digital technologies as enablers of supply chain sustainability in an emerging economy
(Source: Akbari and Hopkins, 2022)
In this regard, the integration of digital technologies into the supply chain operations has become critical to enhancing resilience, particularly in the FMCG sector within the UK. The key digital technologies in this area include the Internet of Things, Artificial Intelligence, blockchain, and big data analytics. IoT applications will involve smart shelves, temperature sensors for perishable goods, and RFID tags for managing inventories. It is forecasted that the IoT market will reach a value of $1.6 trillion by 2025, with supply chain applications named among some of the most prominent investments. The use of IoT in supply chains is likely to enhance their resilience through the facilitation of real-time insights into both the levels of inventory and the condition of products. IoT solutions have been used, for instance, by Tesco in monitoring stock levels and optimising the processes of stock replacement with the effect of minimising the waste of food and enhancing service levels. Artificial Intelligence covers machine learning, natural language processing, and predictive analytics.
Big data analytics is the methodology of looking at large volumes of data to identify patterns, trends, and even correlations. Big data analytics would apply to FMCG in order to make supply chains work more efficiently by bringing in better demand forecasting, reducing wastages, and enhancing efficiency. A study concerning big data analytics at the World Economic Forum estimated that companies able to apply big data analytics to their supply chains could reduce operational costs as high as 15-20% (Yu et al., 2021). This can enable companies to monitor changes in consumer behavior and adjust supply chain strategies, enhancing resilience in the process. Digital technologies can improve supply chain resilience by improving visibility, enabling predictive analytics, enabling agile responses, and addressing concerns about data security. IoT devices and big data analytics help them get timely insights into the level of inventory, shipment status, and fluctuations in demand. It facilitates proactive monitoring of the supply chain by the firm and its ability to react to potential disruptions before they start to mushroom. Predictive analytics, driven by AI and big data, empowers these companies to forecast demand with higher precision, anticipate potential disruptions, and act accordingly. Through this, companies analyze the historical data of the market and external factors and make decisions based on that to build resilience in their supply chain.
Most FMCG companies operate on old and obsolete systems that might not integrate with newer technologies. To eliminate integration problems, the companies must be absolutely clear about their digital strategy and how these technologies can be fitted into the structure of operations. For implementing digital technologies successfully, skilled workforces should be available to deal with and analyse data. Most FMCG firms are short on the required talent in areas related to data analytics, AI, and IoT. Companies therefore have to invest in training and development to upskill their workforce for this area. Collaboration between companies and educational institutions and industry organisations can also help create a pipeline of talent with the right skill-sets to work in a digital supply chain environment.
4.3.3 Developing a Roadmap for Managing Supply Chain Resilience Using Digital Technologies in the UK FMCG Sector
Figure 4.3.3.1: Strategies for building a resilient supply chain
(Source: 3scsolution.com, 2023)
The UK FMCG industry is using digital technologies in the supply chain for resilience. IoT sensors monitor, in real-time, the environmental conditions of manufacturing, retail, storage, and warehouses to maintain product quality and safety. Sensors offer real-time monitoring, automatic deviation warnings, improved product quality, reduced spoilage, safety, improved supply chain visibility, and data-driven informed decisions. Blockchain technology itself embodies transparency, traceability, and security in the supply chain and is also implemented to bring up resilience (Azmi et al., 2022). It allows product tracking, automation of rules and business logic, heightened productivity, and such. In general, blockchain technology implementations require identification of use cases, choice of a platform, development of smart contracts, integration of current systems, training of staff, and testing for security audits. Examples of this include predictive analytics for supply chain process optimisation, interruption detection, and demand forecasting, bringing cost-effectiveness, detection of interruption, optimisation, and effective forecasts.
The benefits of cloud-based technologies could also enable supply chain management, providing real network visibility in real time, with sharing and collaboration. Real-time collaboration, data sharing, end-to-end visibility, scalability, and cost-effectiveness are the main advantages a company may obtain. Setting up the cloud-hosted platforms to meet specific company requirements can be integrated into existing systems. Employee education ensures that such platforms are easily understood and put into practice. It enables cloud-based solutions for order management, inventory management, transportation management, warehouse management, supplier management, demand forecasting, analytics, and reporting. Some of the security and compliance functions are: ensuring data encryption and access controls, legal standards, routine patching, and upgrading of software (Pelluru, 2021). A digital twin can also be built to assess resilience strategies for FMCG industries. This includes predictive analytics, scenario planning, testing, and simulation, real-time monitoring, and collaboration. Sample scenarios include natural disasters, supplier bankruptcy or quality failure, transportation disruptions, demand surges or unexpected changes in direction, and data loss or cybersecurity intrusion. The features that a digital twin embodies include visualisation, modeling, analytics, collaboration, and integration with Internet of Things sensors and other data sources. Stronger readiness for disruptions, greater strategic planning and decision-making, lower risk and better contingency planning, more flexibility and adaptation, and stronger network collaboration and communication are just some of the benefits associated with supply chain resilience. Adopting digital technologies has huge potential to highly improve supply chain resilience within the UK FMCG industry (Ralston and Blackhurst, 2020). This integration of IoT sensors, blockchain technologies, predictive analytics, and cloud-based platforms increases the responsiveness, robustness, and interconnectivity of the supply chain in an enterprise.
Investment in cybersecurity would thus be very critical, as FMCG firms ensure that their supply chain data is protected and there are no disruptions. Some key benefits of investing in cybersecurity include stakeholder confidence, protection of data integrity, supply chain integrity, reduction of risks, assurance of compliance, and business continuity. Cybersecurity protocols might refer to a number of things: say, access controls, encryption of data, network security, training of staff, incident response, vulnerability management, and penetration testing. It is also suggested that one make a cybersecurity awareness program, conduct periodic security audits and risk assessments, plan for disaster recovery, and explore cyber insurance to minimise financial risks. FMCG firms can prevent the breach of supply chain data, avoid disruption of business, and ensure business continuity by investing in cybersecurity. AI-driven chatbots could be important to help increase supply chain resilience and improve customer service experience (Ghosh, Ness and Salunkhe, 2024). Some of the key features that these chatbots would offer include real-time updates, proactive engagement, proactive customer support, 24*7 customer support, personalisation, reduction in number of queries at a help desk, and better satisfaction of customers. The implementation involves selection of an appropriate chatbot platform and integration of the chatbot with supply chain, CRM, and ERP. Scripting, testing, and training form a part of the process. This means end-to-end supply chain visibility through the deployment of supply chain visibility technologies like RFID, barcode scanning, and GPS monitoring, thus reacting quickly to any interruptions. Some benefits include quicker identification and resolution of issues, risks can be managed and mitigated further, higher agility and flexibility, and making better decisions with data-driven insights. Co-opetitive networks among suppliers, logistics companies, and further stakeholders could also be initiated in order to take the resilience in supply chains even further. The various phases of risk assessment include risk possibility determination, determination of the impact of the risk, ranking of risks, making plans to mitigate the risk, execution of the made plans, and monitoring their effectiveness. These might include natural disasters, supply chain disruptions, cybersecurity attacks, market and economic contractions, changes in regulations, or compliance issues, quarterly, semiannual, and annual stress tests. Supply chain resilience has a number of advantages, including proactive identification of vulnerabilities, focused mitigation techniques, better risk management and mitigation, greater agility and flexibility within supply chains, and greater preparedness in terms of disruption and emergencies. These strategies will help FMCG organisations to develop supply chain resilience, reduce disruptions, and ensure business continuity in an ever-changing market environment.
4.4 Discussion
Some of the interview findings, related to the factors hindering the supply chain resilience in the UK FMCG sector were demand fluctuations, macro-level events such as Brexit and COVID 19 pandemic, unreliable suppliers, and disrupted logistics networks. All of these correspond to the first objective of evaluating the supply chain challenges that face the sector (Yang, Fu and Zhang, 2021). The interviews also focused on how the fluctuations of demand results in poor inventory management and how geopolitical tensions tend to result in delay of project and subsequent increase in costs. Also, HGV driver scarcity and rules for sustainability make this problem worse. In the UK FMCG industry, digital technologies could raise productivity and consumer happiness while serving the environmental concern and reducing the risks (Mariani and Fosso Wamba, 2020). AI and automation can accelerate workflows and lower operating costs while increasing response times faster. However, some challenges are high upfront costs, resistance to manage the change, cybersecurity threats, and data privacy concerns. Strategic fit and cultural fit are necessary for addressing critical choices in managing the complexity and meeting the expectations of the growing market.
Agile supply chain architecture allows quick adaptation to changes either in supply or demand (Shashi et al., 2020). Digital technologies can help them achieve thresholds of sustainability, customer satisfaction, and efficiency while gaining visibility. They also meet legal requirements, ensure carbon footprint tracking and reduction, as well as the acquisition of eco-sensitive customers. During the second part of the study, the participants pointed at AI, IoT, blockchain, and employing the cloud computing as the means to improve the supply chain vulnerability. The application of these technologies enhances demand forecasting, supply chain transparency, and flexibility so as to reduce disruptions. However, the respondents have also described further problems with the introduction of these technologies, which have incorporated high initial costs, integration problems, data inaccuracy, and cyber-incidents. However, based on the totality of the information gathered, the participants were optimistic that the supply chain resilience can thrive through the utilization of digital technologies that results to efficiency, customer satisfaction, and unique decision-making authorities.
Digital technologies can provide information, flexibility, and visibility to a business to help be more transparent (Dolgui and Ivanov, 2021). Improves demand forecasting and optimisation of operations and predicts disruption. It minimises processes or reduces them. It requires less startling consistency in monitoring and investment in digital technologies that result in a far stronger supply chain. Furthermore, these solutions meet all the sustainability criteria and are able to provide carbon footprint measurements. Challenges persist in the form of high upfront costs, resistance towards management change, cybersecurity threats, and data privacy concerns. Digital solutions are expected to play a pivotal role in managing supply chain complexity and meeting market demands in the rapidly evolving FMCG industry (Nozari et al., 2021).
Environmental concerns such as climate change, resource depletion, waste management shape the supply chain strategies. The ambitious UK government targets to reach net-zero carbon emissions by 2050 further pressurise the companies to re-evaluate and work towards better sustainability (GOV.UK, 2020). Supply chains contribute more than 80% to a company’s carbon footprint, and hence environmental sustainability is very important for businesses to implement. Events around the world, such as pandemics, natural disasters, and geopolitical conflicts, could also severely affect supply chains. Demand forecasting, inventory optimisation, and customer insights are also done using AI within FMCG. In a study by McKinsey in 2023, it became clear that companies leveraging AI in their supply chain operations were able to achieve a 20-30% gain in efficiency (psico-smart.com, 2022). Blockchain technology provides a decentralised, immutable ledger, hence improving the supply chain a lot in terms of transparency and traceability. Blockchain can be utilised in the FMCG industry for product tracking based on its adherence to safety standards and ethics of sourcing. A Deloitte report states that 40% of FMCG executives operating in the sector believe blockchain will have a profound impact on supply chain operations by 2025 (Hasan et al., 2022). It is due to blockchain that transparency injects itself into supply chains, enabling firms to quickly identify disruptions and devise solutions so that resilience can be built up.
In one report, Cybersecurity Ventures projected that due to cybercrime, estimated annual costs can reach $10.5 trillion by 2025 (Sharif and Mohammed, 2022). It also called for additional cybersecurity measures in organizations accordingly. Sometimes, incorporating new digital technologies into the already existing system is an extremely time-consuming and tiresome process. Shared knowledge and experience, improved coordination and communication, strengthened relations and trust, flexibility and adaptation, and improved risk reduction and management are just a few of the key advantages. The elements that make up a collaborative network approach include establishing a common platform, setting common goals and objectives, data and best-practice sharing, mapping of key stakeholders, and building trust through regular participation and feedback. Regular risk assessments and stress testing are important for the identification of any vulnerabilities and the development of targeted mitigation strategies (Mishra et al., 2020).
Meeting the third objective of establishing the roadmap, there is an idea to plan the digital technology’s implementation in phases. This involves acquisitions in tools such as data analytics, forming strategic alliances with technology vendors, and nurturing workers’ absorptive capacity. Likewise, utilizing end-to-end visibility platform and predictive analytical tools go a long way in preparing and preventing disruption. When integrating different segments in supply chain and handling the issue of cybersecurity risks appropriately, the FMCG companies can improve the construction of the supply chain, thus indicating a higher level of flexibility and responsiveness to shifting market developments.
4.4 Summary
The FMCG sector in the UK enhances supply chain resilience through the usage of digital technologies like AI, IoT, Blockchain, and cloud computing. The technologies enhance information sharing and reduce stockouts and overstocking. Huge initial costs are some of the challenges that come up, including cybersecurity threats, technological issues, and data privacy issues. Accordingly, supply chain managers should have a proper digital strategy while engaging all stakeholders in nurturing the business through developing relationships with technology suppliers and investing in training. Other weaknesses inherent in the sector involve driver shortage, changing fuel prices, and environmental concerns. Digital technologies thus become important for improving supply chain resilience and business continuity against these challenges.
CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
5.1 Conclusion
Supply chains in FMCG are faced with many UK-based bottlenecks because of interaction between customers and decision makers along the various steps of physical distribution, manufacture, wholesale, and retail. These can be overcome by enhancing digitalisation and automation of the supply chain through industry-based technology implementation. These include blockchain, Internet of Things, and machine learning algorithms. The potential benefits brought forth by digital innovations could therefore enhance resilience, sustainability, and competitiveness. The resilient supply chains apply flexible forecasting and contingency planning to adapt to operational disruptions. The FMCG sector is projected to experience a CAGR of 5.4% in the next five years, reaching a value of approximately $15,361.8 billion by 2025 (Becher, 2022). E-commerce also keeps on growing at a far better pace compared to traditional business, and FMCG companies started feeling new opportunities due to customers who want greener and healthier products. Due to prolonged growth and complexity of the supply lines, the organisations operating within the FMCG sector are highly vulnerable to disruption. For the above-mentioned reason, KM is greatly essential for ensuring supply chain resilience. The goal of supply chain resilience should be accomplished by businesses through accurate inventory control, strategic planning, and the establishment of collaborative alliances. The Brexit epidemic developed demand for certain goods, hampered manufacture and distribution, and the supply chain. Lessons learned from past crises and the role of coordinating resources in nurturing or enhancing the elasticity of the avenues of transportation need to inform resilience at the level of supply chains. There is a need for commitment to governance, social justice, and the environment for an FMCG industry to be sustainable. The UK FMCG industry has a long way to go before supply chain resilience is achieved. Embracing sustainable practices, geopolitical issues, and implementing digital transformation are some of the ways through which businesses can cope better with the dynamic supply chain environment for long-term success.
Different challenges affect the FMCG industry, such as volatility in the market, supply chain breakdowns, sustainability, and integrating new technologies. The sector needs digital transformation for openness, responsiveness, and consumer involvement. 47% of FMCG companies mark projection as critical to innovation in the year 2024 since correct forecasting can increase the resilience in the supply chain (Sarker et al., 2022). The dynamic nature of the business environment in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic requires more collaboration, integration, and reorganisation of external and internal resources and talents to minimise disruptions. Resilient supply chains will enable firms to get through current challenges and set up a solid, adaptable future. The methodology of this research is interpretivism, in that it studies stakeholder experiences in the UK FMCG supply chain and helps identify strategies to improve the organisational preparedness of firms for disruptors. Testing hypotheses to find those variables which will enhance the supply chain resilience in the UK involves empirical data collection from FMCG firms through a deductive research technique. The FMCG sector in the UK is adopting digital technologies like cloud computing, blockchain, IoT, and AI to enhance supply chain resilience (Shakur et al., 2024). These technologies ensure efficient processing and help reduce stockouts and overstocking. In any case, issues such as high upfront prices, cybersecurity risks, and data privacy concerns make for inferior adoption. These challenges require investment in training, stakeholder participation, and a clear digital strategy for the sector.
With data-driven decision-making, supplier diversity, agile supply chain design, employee training, and collaboration, digital solutions could enhance supply chain resilience. In addition, the benefits of digital technologies include sustainability, efficiency, visibility, and customer delight. A number of challenges persisting are high upfront costs, resistance to change, cyber threats, integration complexity, and data privacy. There has been the use of digital technology in enhancing supply chain resilience within the UK FMCG sector. IoT sensors monitor the atmosphere within production, retail, storage, and houses to keep the products safe and of quality. The transparency, traceability, and security provided by blockchain technology across the supply chain allow product tracking, automation, and increased productivity (Sunny, Undralla and Madhusudanan Pillai, 2020). Cloud-based technologies make supply chain management more cost-effective while enabling real-time collaboration and data sharing. It is very important to invest in cybersecurity for business continuity and supply chain data security. AI-enabled chatbots will improve customer service, adding more resiliency to the supply chain. Also, risk assessments and regular stress tests must be performed to find the weak points and create focused mitigation plans.
5.2 Research Limitation
A number of major limitations characterise this study on the resilience of supply chains in the FMCG sector of the UK. These include lack of standardisation and academic research regarding resilience measurement, complexity of strategy implementation, geopolitical influence, constraint on data availability and confidentiality, industry specificity, time and resource constraints, and dynamic supply chains. The limitations of resilience methods may make their application in specific industries challenging, necessitating a deep understanding of the subject matter. The research design thus needs to be planned in a way to help the researcher get over such limitations (Tomaszewski, Zarestky and Gonzalez, 2020). This would provide the right platform for incisive analysis relating to supply chain resilience of the FMCG sector of the UK economy. Being aware of such limitations, the researchers can thus think about an agenda of study that is capable of providing real value concerning resilience in this industry and its ability to adjust to a changing climate. They are contributing to the continuous efforts of improving supply chain resilience in the UK FMCG sector.
5.3 Future Prospects
The areas for future research opportunities in the study of supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector of the UK may be formed around innovation and entrepreneurship, policy and regulatory implications, supply chain risk management, supply chain visibility, and transparency. Collaborative resilience strategies, sustainability, digitalisation, global supply chain risks, and risk management comprise dimensions that could form future research coupled with embedding within other disciplines. The research directions will be in the areas of global supply chain risk effects, resilience strategies, transparency, innovation, implications of policies, human factors, sustainable logistics, circular economy, reduction in carbon footprint, stakeholder engagement, sustainable packaging, and adoption of digitalisation and technology.
5.4 Recommendations
The UK FMCG business is recommended to develop a risk management framework to enhance supply chain resilience challenges, involving risk assessment and mitigation throughout the entire supply chain. To enhance resilience, a comprehensive risk management frameworkcomprises risk governance, monitoring and review, risk assessment, risk identification, and communication and reporting of risks.
A company within FMCG can track shipments, manage inventories, analyse performance to find out anomalies, and improve forecasting using supply chain visibility tools. Digital technologies play a crucial role in managing these challenges. These include GPS tracking, RFID, barcode scanning, IoT sensors, cloud-based platforms, data analytics software, and supply chain management systems. These tools facilitate real-time insight into product movement. Some of the hot technologies in demand for all this Supply chain visibility tools include SCM, TMS, WMS, barcode scanning, RFID, cloud-based platforms, Internet of Things sensors, GPS tracking, and data analytics software (Holtschulte, 2022).
A roadmap for managing SC resilience should include developing cooperative relationships with suppliers, logistics companies, and other stakeholders is indispensable in any supply chain. On the issues of technology enablement in support, regular communication, setting expectations clearly, trust-transparency, solving problems collaboratively, performance metrics, training and development opportunities, incentives and rewards, sharing risks, flexibility, adaptability empowered through technology, FMCG companies take forward supply chain resilience, better communication, heightened trust, innovation motivation, cost reduction, quality enhancement, agility, and risk management.
The only way to act quickly on disruptions, changing consumer demand, and shifting market conditions is by investing in the agility of the supply chain. Modular supply chain design, in concert with flexible manufacturing and multisourcing, is pursued to create supply chains that can flex and adapt (Badejo and Ierapetritou, 2022). Delay strategy, dynamic inventory management, real-time visibility, collaborative planning, and scenario planning, investment in blockchain, artificial intelligence, and the Internet of Things are some of the tactics used.
It is also suggested that a business continuity plan should be developed, and investment in personnel training and development; implementation of appropriate environmental practices; regular risk assessments are performed. A diverse base of suppliers should be encouraged, innovation and technology harnessed, a supply chain resilience team developed, and a communication plan formulated. With these recommendations implemented, FMCG companies in the UK can make their supply chains resilient and therefore respond in a professional manner to disruptions.
References
3scsolution.com. (2023). Top 7 Strategies for Building a Resilient Supply Chain. [online] Available at: https://3scsolution.com/insight/supply-chain-resilience-strategies.
admin_purestaff (2023). How Big Is The FMCG Market In The UK? – Pure Staff Blog. [online] Pure Staff. Available at: https://www.purestaff.co.uk/how-big-is-the-fmcg-market-in-the-uk/.
Aityassine, F., Soumadi, M., Aldiabat, B., Al-Shorman, H., Akour, I., Alshurideh, M. and Al-Hawary, S., (2022). The effect of supply chain resilience on supply chain performance of chemical industrial companies. Uncertain Supply Chain Management, 10(4), pp.1271-1278. http://growingscience.com/uscm/Vol10/uscm_2022_84.pdf
Akbari, M. and Hopkins, J.L. (2022). Digital technologies as enablers of supply chain sustainability in an emerging economy. Operations Management Research, [online] 15, pp.689–710. doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s12063-021-00226-8.
Akyıldız, S.T. and Ahmed, K.H., (2021). An overview of qualitative research and focus group discussion. International Journal of Academic Research in Education, 7(1), pp.1-15.DOI: 10.17985/ijare.866762
Albukhitan, S. (2020). Developing digital transformation strategy for manufacturing. Procedia computer science, 170, 664-671. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877050920306372/pdf?md5=0a2803ea59507023fc85a80b9ade5b6e&pid=1-s2.0-S1877050920306372-main.pdf
Alfarsi, F., Lemke, F. and Yang, Y., (2019). The importance of supply chain resilience: an empirical investigation. Procedia Manufacturing, 39, pp.1525-1529. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2351978920303590/pdf?md5=676a49fa327d566ffa4a8fa6ea2482d0&pid=1-s2.0-S2351978920303590-main.pdf
Alkaraan, F., Albitar, K., Hussainey, K., and Venkatesh, V. G. (2022). Corporate transformation toward Industry 4.0 and financial performance: The influence of environmental, social, and governance (ESG). Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 175, 121423. https://research.bangor.ac.uk/portal/files/71273517/Corporate_transformation_toward_Industry_4.0_and_financial_performance.pdf
Allsop, D.B., Chelladurai, J.M., Kimball, E.R., Marks, L.D. and Hendricks, J.J., (2022). Qualitative methods with Nvivo software: A practical guide for analyzing qualitative data. Psych, 4(2), pp.142-159.https://doi.org/10.3390/psych4020013
Ashfaq, A. (2022). Application of blockchain technology & iot based smart sensors in supply chain management via business development approach. [online] webthesis.biblio.polito.it. Available at: https://webthesis.biblio.polito.it/22542/.
Aslam, H., Blome, C., Roscoe, S., and Azhar, T. M. (2020). Determining the antecedents of dynamic supply chain capabilities. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 25(4), 427-442. https://sussex.figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/Determining_the_antecedents_of_dynamic_supply_chain_capabilities/23473544/1/files/41181800.pdf
Attaran, M., (2020), July. Digital technology enablers and their implications for supply chain management. In Supply Chain Forum: An International Journal (Vol. 21, No. 3, pp. 158-172). Taylor & Francis. https://elearning.cendekiaku.com/storage/materi/file/1681343218.pdf
Autere, O. and Sandnes, J. (2023). Beyond Borders: The Ability of FMCG Companies Leveraging their Internal Capabilities Internationally. [online] Available at: https://lup.lub.lu.se/luur/download?func=downloadFile&recordOId=9131341&fileOId=913134
Azmi, N.A., Sweis, G., Sweis, R. and Sammour, F. (2022). Exploring Implementation of Blockchain for the Supply Chain Resilience and Sustainability of the Construction Industry in Saudi Arabia. Sustainability, 14(11), p.6427. doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/su14116427.
Badejo, O. and Ierapetritou, M.G. (2022). Mathematical Programming Approach to Optimize Tactical and Operational Supply Chain Decisions under Disruptions. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 61(45), pp.16747–16763. doi:https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.iecr.2c01641.
Becher, E. (2022). Shared value creation through integrated reporting in the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) Industry : an analysis of the effect of Corporate Social Performance (CSP) on the Corporate Financial Performance (CFP) of multinational companies. [online] repositorio.ucp.pt. Available at: https://repositorio.ucp.pt/handle/10400.14/41106.
Bechtsis, D., Tsolakis, N., Iakovou, E. and Vlachos, D. (2021). Data-driven secure, resilient and sustainable supply chains: gaps, opportunities, and a new generalised data sharing and data monetisation framework. International Journal of Production Research, 60(14), pp.1–21. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2021.1957506.
Belhadi, A., Mani, V., Kamble, S. S., Khan, S. A. R., and Verma, S. (2024). Artificial intelligence-driven innovation for enhancing supply chain resilience and performance under the effect of supply chain dynamism: an empirical investigation. Annals of Operations Research, 333(2), 627-652. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10479-021-03956-x.pdf
Bowers, D., Matlala, N., Berhadien, M., Salie, U.H. and Gongxeka, T., (2024). Sustainable Supply Chain Management and Disruptive Theory: a Bibliometric Review. Management of Sustainable Development, 16(1), pp.11-23.https://doi.org/10.3390/su13126535
Bryce, C., Ring, P., Ashby, S., and Wardman, J. K. (2022). Resilience in the face of uncertainty: early lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic. In COVID-19 (pp. 48-55). Routledge. https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/24037/1/RJRR-2020-0126.R1_Proof_hi.pdf
Calvo, J., Olmo, J.L.D. and Berlanga, V., (2020). Supply chain resilience and agility: a theoretical literature review. International Journal of Supply Chain and Operations Resilience, 4(1), pp.37-69. https://www.academia.edu/download/62807148/f84111273519261020200403-80977-1d647ps.pdf
Campbell, S., Greenwood, M., Prior, S., Shearer, T., Walkem, K., Young, S., … & Walker, K. (2020). Purposive sampling: complex or simple? Research case examples. Journal of research in Nursing, 25(8), 652-661. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7932468/
Carissimi, M.C., Prataviera, L.B., Creazza, A., Melacini, M. and Dallari, F., (2023). Blurred lines: the timeline of supply chain resilience strategies in the grocery industry in the time of Covid-19. Operations management research, 16(1), pp.80-98.https://doi.org/10.1007/s12063-022-00278-4
Casula, M., Rangarajan, N. and Shields, P., (2021). The potential of working hypotheses for deductive exploratory research. Quality & Quantity, 55(5), pp.1703-1725.https://doi.org/10.1007/s11135-020-01072-9
Chang, J. (2019). Supply chain management has surely evolved throughout the years. For instance, the role of supply chains in pr. [online] Financesonline.com. Available at: https://financesonline.com/supply-chain-statistics/.
Christopher, M., and Peck, H. (2004). Building the resilient supply chain. International Journal of Logistics Management, 15(2), 1-13. doi:10.1108/09574090410700275
Creazza, A., Colicchia, C., Spiezia, S. and Dallari, F., (2022). Who cares? Supply chain managers’ perceptions regarding cyber supply chain risk management in the digital transformation era. Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 27(1), pp.30-53. https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/SCM-02-2020-0073/full/pdf
De Filippi, P., Mannan, M., and Reijers, W. (2020). Blockchain as a confidence machine: The problem of trust and challenges of governance. Technology in Society, 62, 101284. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/am/pii/S0160791X20303067
Dolgui, A. and Ivanov, D. (2021). 5G in digital supply chain and operations management: fostering flexibility, end-to-end connectivity and real-time visibility through internet-of-everything. International Journal of Production Research, 60(2), pp.1–10. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2021.2002969.
Du, J. and Shepotylo, O. (2021). UK Trade in the Time of COVID‐19: A Review. The World Economy, [online] 45(5). doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/twec.13220.
Dubey, R., Bryde, D. J., Dwivedi, Y. K., Graham, G., Foropon, C., and Papadopoulos, T. (2023). Dynamic digital capabilities and supply chain resilience: The role of government effectiveness. International Journal of Production Economics, 258, 108790. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0925527323000221
Elfawal, A., Ragheb, M.A. and Adel, R., (2021). Supply chain management practices, innovation capabilities and operational performance: An empirical evidence from the FMCG sector. The business and management review, 12(1), pp.70-81. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Riham-Adel/publication/354586650_Supply_chain_management_practices_innovation_capabilities_and_operational_performance_An_empirical_evidence_from_the_FMCG_sector/links/6140ff49578238365b0b1181/Supply-chain-management-practices-innovation-capabilities-and-operational-performance-An-empirical-evidence-from-the-FMCG-sector.pdf
Ermes, T., Henderson, N., Staude, Z. and Niemann, W., (2022). Supply chain disruption propagation: A study of South African fast-moving consumer goods food and beverage manufacturers. Acta Commercii, 22(1), pp.1-12.https://doi.org/10.1111/ejed.12014
Falatouri, T., Darbanian, F., Brandtner, P. and Udokwu, C. (2022). Predictive Analytics for Demand Forecasting – A Comparison of SARIMA and LSTM in Retail SCM. Procedia Computer Science, 200(1877-0509), pp.993–1003. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procs.2022.01.298.
Fonseca, L.M. and Azevedo, A.L. (2020). COVID- 19: outcomes for Global Supply Chains. Management & Marketing. Challenges for the Knowledge Society, [online] 15(1), pp.424–438. doi:https://doi.org/10.2478/mmcks-2020-0025.
Galushko, V. and Riabchyk, A. (2024). The demand for online grocery shopping: COVID-induced changes in grocery shopping behavior of Canadian consumers. PLOS ONE, 19(2), pp.e0295538–e0295538. doi:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0295538.
Ghosh, S., Ness, S. and Salunkhe, S. (2024). The Role of AI Enabled Chatbots in Omnichannel Customer Service. Journal of Engineering Research and Reports, 26(6), pp.327–345. doi:https://doi.org/10.9734/jerr/2024/v26i61184.
GOV.UK (2020). UK sets ambitious new climate target ahead of UN Summit. [online] GOV.UK. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-sets-ambitious-new-climate-target-ahead-of-un-summit.
Haider Ali Javaid (2024). The Future of Financial Services: Integrating AI for Smarter, More Efficient Operations. MZ Journal of Artificial Intelligence, [online] 1(2). Available at: http://mzjournal.com/index.php/MZJAI/article/view/239.
Hasan, N., Ferdouse, N., Khan, T., Adiba, A.F. and Shams, K.A.I. (2022). Implementing Blockchain in the supply chain of FMCG companies for better demand forecasting and logistics operation. Supply Chain Insider | ISSN: 2617-7420 (Print), 2617-7420 (Online), [online] 8(1). Available at: https://supplychaininsider.org/ojs/index.php/home/article/view/18.
Hastig, G.M. and Sodhi, M.S., (2020). Blockchain for supply chain traceability: Business requirements and critical success factors. Production and Operations Management, 29(4), pp.935-954.https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.13147
Holloway, S., (2024). The Impact of Supply Chain Visibility on Marketing Strategies in the Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) Industry. https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202406.1584/download/final_file
Holtschulte, A. (2022). IoT and Enterprise Software. Digital Supply Chain and Logistics with IoT, pp.95–124. doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-89408-5_4.
Hong, Z. and Zahid, R.M.A. (2023). The Security of Global Value Chains (GVC): Recent Trends, Challenges, and Future Risk Management. [online] Emerging Trends in Sustainable Supply Chain Management and Green Logistics. Available at: https://www.igi-global.com/chapter/the-security-of-global-value-chains-gvc/315231.
Ivanov, D. and Dolgui, A., (2021). A digital supply chain twin for managing the disruption risks and resilience in the era of Industry 4.0. Production Planning & Control, 32(9), pp.775-788. https://scholar.archive.org/work/zy3vujxkxvhybkvcllym554xk4/access/wayback/https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/09537287.2020.1768450?needAccess=true
Ivanov, D., and Dolgui, A. (2020). Viability of intertwined supply networks: Extending the supply chain resilience angles towards survivability. International Journal of Production Research, 58(10), 2904-2915. doi:10.1080/00207543.2020.1750727
Ivanov, D., and Dolgui, A. (2021). A digital supply chain twin for managing the disruption risks and resilience in the era of Industry 4.0. Production Planning and Control, 32(9), 775-788. https://scholar.archive.org/work/zy3vujxkxvhybkvcllym554xk4/access/wayback/https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/09537287.2020.1768450?needAccess=true
Jha, A.K., Agi, M.A. and Ngai, E.W., (2020). A note on big data analytics capability development in supply chain. Decision Support Systems, 138, p.113382.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dss.2020.113382
Kazancoglu, I., Ozbiltekin-Pala, M., Mangla, S.K., Kazancoglu, Y. and Jabeen, F., (2022). Role of flexibility, agility and responsiveness for sustainable supply chain resilience during COVID-19. Journal of Cleaner Production, 362, p.132431. http://pure.jgu.edu.in/id/eprint/3840/1/Role%20of%20flexibility.pdf
Kerekes, D. and Adamsson, E. (2020). Trade wars, Brexit and Pandemics – A strategy for survival in a turbulent world : A case study on a global FMCG company. [online] DIVA. Available at: https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2:1447891.
Khan, S. I. H. S. (2020). Geo-Politics of Syrian Conflict: Role of Regional, Extra-Regional and Non-State Actors in the Situation. https://pssr.org.pk/issues/v4/2/geo-politics-of-syrian-conflict-role-of-regional-extra-regional-and-non-state-actors-in-the-situation.pdf
Khan, S.A.R., Piprani, A.Z. and Yu, Z., (2022). Digital technology and circular economy practices: future of supply chains. Operations Management Research, 15(3), pp.676-688. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Arsalan-Piprani/publication/360527782_Digital_technology_and_circular_economy_practices_future_of_supply_chains/links/627e13b3107cae2919a1d2aa/Digital-technology-and-circular-economy-practices-future-of-supply-chains.pdf?_sg%5B0%5D=started_experiment_milestone&_sg%5B1%5D=started_experiment_milestone&origin=journalDetail
Khan, Y., Su’ud, M. B. M., Alam, M. M., Ahmad, S. F., Ahmad, A. Y. B., and Khan, N. (2022). Application of internet of things (iot) in sustainable supply chain management. Sustainability, 15(1), 694. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/15/1/694/pdf
Končar, J., Grubor, A., Marić, R., Vučenović, S. and Vukmirović, G., (2020). Setbacks to IoT implementation in the function of FMCG supply chain sustainability during COVID-19 pandemic. Sustainability, 12(18), p.7391. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/12/18/7391/pdf
Končar, J., Grubor, A., Marić, R., Vučenović, S. and Vukmirović, G. (2020). Setbacks to IoT Implementation in the Function of FMCG Supply Chain Sustainability during COVID-19 Pandemic. Sustainability, [online] 12(18), p.7391. doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/su12187391.
KPMG (2022). Big Shifts, Small Steps. [online] Available at: https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/se/pdf/komm/2022/Global-Survey-of-Sustainability-Reporting-2022.pdf.
KPMG (2023). The future of the supply chain. [online] Available at: https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2023/09/kpmg-future-of-supply-chain-report.pdf.
Lavri, O. (2023). Why the UK is struggling with a driver shortage. [online] HRForecast. Available at: https://hrforecast.com/why-the-uk-is-struggling-with-a-driver-shortage/.
Li, J. Y., Sun, R., Tao, W., and Lee, Y. (2021). Employee coping with organizational change in the face of a pandemic: The role of transparent internal communication. Public relations review, 47(1), 101984. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9758076/
Madhavi, B.R.H. and Wickramarachchi, R. (2021). Decision-making models for a resilient supply chain in FMCG companies during a pandemic: A systematic literature review. [online] IEEE Xplore. doi:https://doi.org/10.1109/SCSE53661.2021.9568303.
Mariani, M.M. and Fosso Wamba, S. (2020). Exploring how consumer goods companies innovate in the digital age: The role of big data analytics companies. Journal of Business Research, [online] 121, pp.338–352. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0148296320305956.
Mishra, S., Anderson, K., Miller, B., Boyer, K. and Warren, A. (2020). Microgrid resilience: A holistic approach for assessing threats, identifying vulnerabilities, and designing corresponding mitigation strategies. Applied Energy, 264, p.114726. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2020.114726.
Mohajan, H.K., (2020). Quantitative research: A successful investigation in natural and social sciences. Journal of Economic Development, Environment and People, 9(4), pp.50-79.https://doi.org/10.4102/sajim.v5i4.380
Mubarik, M.S., Naghavi, N., Mubarik, M., Kusi-Sarpong, S., Khan, S.A., Zaman, S.I. and Kazmi, S.H.A., (2021). Resilience and cleaner production in industry 4.0: Role of supply chain mapping and visibility. Journal of cleaner production, 292, p.126058. https://shura.shu.ac.uk/32469/3/Kusi-Sarpong-ResilienceAndCleaner%20productionInIndustry%28AM%29.pdf
Munir, M., Jajja, M. S. S., and Chatha, K. A. (2022). Capabilities for enhancing supply chain resilience and responsiveness in the COVID-19 pandemic: exploring the role of improvisation, anticipation, and data analytics capabilities. International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 42(10), 1576-1604. https://repository.lboro.ac.uk/articles/journal_contribution/Capabilities_for_enhancing_supply_chain_resilience_and_responsiveness_in_the_COVID-19_pandemic_exploring_the_role_of_improvisation_anticipation_and_data_analytics_capabilities/21517608/1/files/38141163.pdf
Munir, M., Jajja, M.S.S. and Chatha, K.A., (2022). Capabilities for enhancing supply chain resilience and responsiveness in the COVID-19 pandemic: exploring the role of improvisation, anticipation, and data analytics capabilities. International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 42(10), pp.1576-1604.https://doi.org/10.1108/IJOPM-11-2021-0677
Nayal, P., Pandey, N., and Paul, J. (2022). Covid‐19 pandemic and consumer‐employee‐organization wellbeing: A dynamic capability theory approach. Journal of Consumer Affairs, 56(1), 359-390. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8447057/
Neboh, N.D. and Mbhele, T.P. (2021). Supply chain design dimensions for supply chain resilience in the South African fast-moving consumer goods retail industry. Africa Journal of Management, pp.1–24. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/23322373.2021.1930742.
Neboh, N.D. and Mbhele, T.P., (2021). Supply chain design dimensions for supply chain resilience in the South African fast-moving consumer goods retail industry. Africa Journal of Management, 7(sup1), pp.58-81.https://doi.org/10.1080/23322373.2021.1930742
Nozari, H., Fallah, M., Kazemipoor, H. and Najafi, S.E. (2021). Big data analysis of IoT-based supply chain management considering FMCG industries. Бизнес-информатика, [online] 15(1 (eng)), pp.78–96. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/big-data-analysis-of-iot-based-supply-chain-management-considering-fmcg-industries.
Nozari, H., Szmelter-Jarosz, A. and Ghahremani-Nahr, J. (2022). Analysis of the Challenges of Artificial Intelligence of Things (AIoT) for the Smart Supply Chain (Case Study: FMCG Industries). Sensors, [online] 22(8), p.2931. Available at: https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/22/8/2931.
Núñez-Merino, M., Maqueira-Marín, J.M., Moyano-Fuentes, J. and Martínez-Jurado, P.J., (2020). Information and digital technologies of Industry 4.0 and Lean supply chain management: a systematic literature review. International Journal of Production Research, 58(16), pp.5034-5061. https://zaguan.unizar.es/record/101540/files/texto_completo.pdf
Odulaja, B.A., Oke, T., Eleogu, T., Abdul, A.A. and Daraojimba, H.O. (2023). Resilience in the face of uncertainty: a review on the impact of supply chain volatility amid ongoing geopolitical disruptions. International journal of applied research in social sciences, 5(10), pp.463–486.
Oriekhoe, O. I., Oyeyemi, O. P., Bello, B. G., Omotoye, G. B., Daraojimba, A. I., and Adefemi, A. (2024). Blockchain in supply chain management: A review of efficiency, transparency, and innovation. International Journal of Science and Research Archive, 11(1), 173-181. https://ijsra.net/sites/default/files/IJSRA-2024-0028.pdf
Ozdemir, D., Sharma, M., Dhir, A. and Daim, T., (2022). Supply chain resilience during the COVID-19 pandemic. Technology in society, 68, p.101847. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8771080/
Park, D., Bahrudin, F.I. and Han, J., (2020). Circular reasoning for the evolution of research through a strategic construction of research methodologies. International Journal of Quantitative and Qualitative Research Methods, 8(3), pp.1-23.doi: 10.17265/2160-6579/2018.04.003
Pelluru, K. (2021). Integrate security practices and compliance requirements into DevOps processes. MZ Computing Journal, [online] 2(2), pp.1−19–1−19. Available at: http://mzjournal.com/index.php/MZCJ/article/view/139.
Pettit, S., Wang, Y. and Beresford, A. (2022). Chapter 7 – The impact of digitalization on contemporary and future logistics. [online] ScienceDirect. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780323916141000071.
Pimenta, M.L., Cezarino, L.O., Piato, E.L., da Silva, C.H.P., Oliveira, B.G. and Liboni, L.B., (2022). Supply chain resilience in a Covid-19 scenario: Mapping capabilities in a systemic framework. Sustainable Production and Consumption, 29, pp.649-656.https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.spc.2021.10.012
Piprani, A.Z., Aziz, A. and Ahmad, Z., (2021). Prioritising lean, agile, resilient and green supply chain practices: an application of analytical hierarchy process (AHP) in FMCG sector of Pakistan. JISR management and social sciences & economics, 19(2), pp.1-20.https://doi.org/10.31384/jisrmsse/2021.19.2.1
Piprani, A.Z., Jaafar, N.I., Ali, S.M., Mubarik, M.S. and Shahbaz, M., (2022). Multi-dimensional supply chain flexibility and supply chain resilience: the role of supply chain risks exposure. Operations Management Research, 15(1), pp.307-325. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s12063-021-00232-w.pdf
Priya, A., (2021). Case study methodology of qualitative research: Key attributes and navigating the conundrums in its application. Sociological Bulletin, 70(1), pp.94-110.https://doi.org/10.1177/0038022920970318
psico-smart.com (2022). What role does artificial intelligence play in optimizing supply chain processes? [online] Psico-smart.com. Available at: https://psico-smart.com/en/blogs/blog-what-role-does-artificial-intelligence-play-in-optimizing-supply-chain-processes-88010#:~:text=According%20to%20a%20McKinsey%20report [Accessed 10 Sep. 2024].
Queiroz, M.M., Wamba, S.F., Jabbour, C.J.C. and Machado, M.C., (2022). Supply chain resilience in the UK during the coronavirus pandemic: A resource orchestration perspective. International Journal of Production Economics, 245, p.108405.https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.ijpe.2021.108405
Ralston, P. and Blackhurst, J. (2020). Industry 4.0 and resilience in the supply chain: a driver of capability enhancement or capability loss? International Journal of Production Research, 58(16), pp.5006–5019. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2020.1736724.
Şababoğlu, R. and Özden, Ü.H., (2024). Investigation of Risks and Risk Management Practices in The Fast-Moving Consumer Goods Sector in Turkey with an Interview Study. OPUS Journal of Society Research, 21(2), pp.109-120.https://doi.org/10.26466/opusjsr.1398921
Salmi, V. (2024). Utilising Supply Chain Visibility for creating more resilient Supply Chains: How Internet of Things, Digital Twins and Cloud Computing can enhance visibility and create more resilient supply chains. [online] http://www.doria.fi. Available at: https://www.doria.fi/handle/10024/189063.
Sarker, S., Rashidi, K., Gölgeci, I., Gligor, D.M. and Hsuan, J. (2022). Exploring pillars of supply chain competitiveness: insights from leading global supply chains. Production Planning & Control, pp.1–18.
Shakur, M.S., Lubaba, M., Debnath, B., Bari, A.M. and Rahman, M.A., (2024). Exploring the Challenges of Industry 4.0 Adoption in the FMCG Sector: Implications for Resilient Supply Chain in Emerging Economy. Logistics, 8(1), p.27.https://doi.org/10.3390/logistics8010027
Sharif, M.H.U. and Mohammed, M.A. (2022). A literature review of financial losses statistics for cyber security and future trend. World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, [online] 15(1), pp.138–156. doi:https://doi.org/10.30574/wjarr.2022.15.1.0573.
Sharma, A., and Sharma, R. P. (2023). A research study on eco-friendly green products: Understanding consumer perceptions and preferences. Globus-An International Journal of Management and IT, 14(2), 81-83. https://globusjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/GMIT-142-JJ23-11.-Arpit-Sharma.pdf
Shashi, Centobelli, P., Cerchione, R. and Ertz, M. (2020). Agile supply chain management: where did it come from and where will it go in the era of digital transformation? Industrial Marketing Management, [online] 90(1), pp.324–345. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indmarman.2020.07.011.
Sheel, A., and Nath, V. (2020). Blockchain technology adoption in the supply chain (UTAUT2 with risk)–evidence from Indian supply chains. International Journal of Applied Management Science, 12(4), 324-346. https://www.academia.edu/download/103669741/ijams.2020.11034420230623-1-fvrl0v.pdf
Shobhana, N. (2024). AI-Powered Supply Chains Towards Greater Efficiency. [online] http://www.igi-global.com. Available at: https://www.igi-global.com/chapter/ai-powered-supply-chains-towards-greater-efficiency/339750.
Sodhi, M.S., Tang, C.S. and Willenson, E.T. (2021). Research opportunities in preparing supply chains of essential goods for future pandemics. International Journal of Production Research, 61(8), pp.1–16. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2021.1884310.
Sony, M. and Mekoth, N. (2022). Employee adaptability skills for Industry 4.0 success: a road map. Production & Manufacturing Research, [online] 10(1), pp.24–41. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/21693277.2022.2035281.
Sunny, J., Undralla, N. and Madhusudanan Pillai, V. (2020). Supply chain transparency through blockchain-based traceability: An overview with demonstration. Computers & Industrial Engineering, [online] 150(150), p.106895. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2020.106895.
Talwar, S., Kaur, P., Fosso Wamba, S., and Dhir, A. (2021). Big Data in operations and supply chain management: a systematic literature review and future research agenda. International Journal of Production Research, 59(11), 3509-3534. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/00207543.2020.1868599
Tanudiharjo, R., Yun, F., Joo, J. and Arokiam, I., (2021). Investigation of factors impacting lean implementation in the Indonesian fast-moving consumer goods industry. Operations and Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 14(2), pp.162-172.https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2599439
Tarai, R.K. (2020). The Implications of Ai In Enhancing Fmcg Industries. PalArch’s Journal of Archaeology of Egypt / Egyptology, [online] 17(9), pp.6505–6522. Available at: https://archives.palarch.nl/index.php/jae/article/view/5210.
Tamilmani, K., Rana, N. P., Wamba, S. F., and Dwivedi, R. (2021). The extended Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT2): A systematic literature review and theory evaluation. International Journal of Information Management, 57, 102269. https://bradscholars.brad.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/10454/18159/tamilmani-et-al-2020.pdf?sequence=5&isAllowed=y
Tarigan, Z.J.H., Siagian, H. and Jie, F., (2021). Impact of internal integration, supply chain partnership, supply chain agility, and supply chain resilience on sustainable advantage. Sustainability, 13(10), p.5460. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/13/10/5460/pdf
Teece, D.J., (2018). Business models and dynamic capabilities. Long range planning, 51(1), pp.40-49. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0024630117302868
Tomaszewski, L.E., Zarestky, J. and Gonzalez, E. (2020). Planning qualitative research: Design and decision making for new researchers. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 19(1), pp.1–7. doi:https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406920967174.
Umunnakwe, A., Huang, H., Oikonomou, K. and Davis, K.R., (2021). Quantitative analysis of power systems resilience: Standardization, categorizations, and challenges. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 149, p.111252.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2021.111252
Van Droogenbroeck, E., and Van Hove, L. (2021). Adoption and usage of E-grocery shopping: A context-specific UTAUT2 model. Sustainability, 13(8), 4144. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/13/8/4144/pdf
Wulandhari, N. B. I., Budhwar, P., Mishra, N., Akbar, S., Do, Q., and Milligan, G. (2023). Organizational resilience to supply chain risks during the COVID‐19 pandemic. British Journal of Management, 34(3), 1282-1315. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/1467-8551.12648
Yang, M., Fu, M. and Zhang, Z., (2021). The adoption of digital technologies in supply chains: Drivers, process and impact. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 169, p.120795. https://ore.exeter.ac.uk/repository/bitstream/handle/10871/125543/[2021]%20TFSC_digital%20technology_Accepted%20version.pdf?sequence=1
Yu, W., Wong, C.Y., Chavez, R. and Jacobs, M.A. (2021). Integrating big data analytics into supply chain finance: The roles of information processing and data-driven culture. International Journal of Production Economics, 236(1), p.108135. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2021.108135.
Zavala-Alcívar, A., Verdecho, M. J., and Alfaro-Saiz, J. J. (2020). A conceptual framework to manage resilience and increase sustainability in the supply chain. Sustainability, 12(16), 6300. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/12/16/6300/pdf
Żurek, J. 1, Rudy, M. 2 1 D. of F.M., Public Finance, I. of E., Finance, C. of S.S., Processing, email protected] 2 D. of A., Commodity Science, I. of F. and Nutrition Technology, C. of N.S. (2024). Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Changes in Consumer Purchasing Behavior in the Food Market with a Focus on Meat and Meat Products—A Comprehensive Literature Review. ProQuest, [online] p.933. doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/foods13060933.
Appendix: Sample Interview Questionnaire
Interviewee 1
Demographic questions
- Which age group do you belong to?
25
- What is your role in the industry?
Supply Chain Manager
- What is your gender?
Male
- What is your professional background?
Logistics/Supply Chain Management
Survey questions
- Do you agree that there are resilience challenges in the supply chain in the UK FMCG sector? If yes, what are the resilience challenges? If not, why do you think so?
Yes, I completely agree with this. Most certainly, they absolutely agree that the supply chain resilience of FMCG in the UK is facing big challenges. First, demand volatility, established by economic fluctuation, change in consumer preference, and seasonal variation, is the main challenge. Besides these, external disruptions-like Brexit and the COVID-19 pandemic-have shown that supply chains are vulnerable to delays and increased costs. Add to that the complication of an international supply chain with a variety of geopolitical tensions and trade regulations adding their own flavor of unpredictability. Sustainability involves balancing operational efficiency with environmental friendliness.
2. What digital technologies are used for supply chain resilience in the FMCG sector in the UK?
In this regard, digital-determined key technologies include artificial intelligence for demand forecasting, the Internet of Things regarding real-time inventory and logistics monitoring, blockchain for transparency and traceability, and cloud computing for managing data between supply chain partners. These technologies will facilitate the firm in reducing the probability of stockouts and overstocking of goods in inventories, enhance the transparency of transactions, and ensure smooth processing. This, in turn, helps in maintaining better communication and taking well-versed decisions.
3. According to you what strategies can be developed to manage supply chain resilience using digital technologies in the FMCG sector in the UK?
As per my opinion supply chain resilience can be enhanced using AI and data analytics to improve demand forecasting and inventory management. Suppliers, manufacturing, and retailers can use different digital platforms to have better collaboration in responding faster in the event of disruption. Investment can be made in supply chain visibility solutions, such as IoT devices and tracking software that give real-time visibility into supply chain issues. Sound contingency planning can be done for a number of disruptions with the help of digital tools, presenting an opportunity to effectively communicate and prepare.
4. What are the benefits of implementing digital technologies in enhancing supply chain resilience within the UK FMCG sector?
The supply chain resilience for the UK FMCG industry can hugely be improved by the use of digital technologies. This would be facilitated by enabling real-time visibility, automation of procedures, supplying collaboration, managing inventories better, making enterprises agile, better decision-making, product quality, reduction in costs, customer satisfaction, adherence to regulatory elements, supply chain flexibility, reduced carbon footprint, asset utilisation, and enhancing knowledge sharing. With the application of these technologies, supply chain managers can build a far more flexible, efficient, and resilient chain that can absorb disruptions and changing market conditions much better.
5.What are the challenges or disadvantages associated with implementing digital technologies in enhancing supply chain resilience within the UK FMCG sector?
The reasons for the UK FMCG industries not being able to strengthen supply chains are high upfront investments, complex technology integration, data quality issues, cybersecurity concerns, overreliance on technology, lack of skill, change management, cultural opposition, and non-digital partnerships. Clear digital strategy, stakeholder’s engagement, investment in training, and partnership with technology providers will help them to overcome the challenges. This can also be improved by blockchain, AI, IoT sensors, cloud-based platforms, and robotics for data-driven decision making, visibility, demand forecast, risk management, collaboration, efficiency, productivity, reduction of costs, quality of products, and inventory management.
6. What is your final thought on digital technologies playing great roles in developing a road map to develop a more resilient supply chain?
I think digital technologies are the basis on which supply chain managers base their plans and work out a roadmap for a resilient supply chain. They enable data-driven decision-making, extended collaboration, real-time visibility, predictive analytics, and automation. Productivity, agility, transparency, efficiency, and a customer-oriented mindset could be increased, while costs could be cut by implementing cloud computing, blockchain, AI, and IoT technologies. It would be executed in some steps: assessment of the state of digital maturity, locating development areas, creating a perfectly clear digital strategy, investment in digital infrastructure and technology, and cultivation of an innovative and always-learning culture. With digital technology integration, the supply chains become resilient to handle various kinds of disturbances and can thrive in a highly dynamic and complex environment.
Keywords: distinction level dissertation sample
distinction sample sentence
dissertation grading system
dissertation with distinction
graduation distinction levels
thesis distinction
academic distinctions examples
a dissertation
academic distinction definition
distinction dissertation example
distinction dissertation
distinction masters dissertation example
criminal justice dissertation examples
completed dissertation examples
example of dissertation
exemple d’une dissertation en français
example of dissertation outline
fsu distinctions
fsu dissertation formatting
formal distinction example
graduate distinction
gpa distinctions
honors dissertation
high distinction unl
honors distinction college
dissertation-in-practice
dissertation scores
jd distinction
jmu dissertations
jackson state university dissertation guidelines
ku dissertation formatting
kent state dissertation guidelines
ksu dissertations
level of distinction
la dissertation littéraire
latin distinctions
ms dissertation
sample dissertation outline
purpose statement dissertation examples
qualitative dissertation sample
qualitative dissertation examples
qualitative dissertation outline
qualitative dissertation template
sample quantitative dissertation
research distinction
what is the difference between distinction and high distinction
typical dissertation length
type de dissertation
unique distinction
unl dissertation format
un exemple de dissertation
distinction uva
wset level 3 distinction rate
wset distinction
written dissertation
yale distinction in the major
yale dissertation format
yale dissertation submission
dissertation length
sample dissertation presentation
zotero dissertation
normal dissertation length
average dissertation length by discipline
sample dissertation chapter 1
dissertation chapter 1 example
3 minute dissertation
three-article dissertation examples
dissertation chapter 4 sample
dissertation chapter 4 example
5 chapter dissertation format
dissertation chapter 5 sample
sample dissertation topics
dissertation (6)
sample dissertation apa 7th edition
sample apa 7 dissertation
dissertation format apa 7th edition
apa 7 dissertation example
what is the format of a dissertation
dissertation outline example pdfprimary research dissertation sample
primary research essay examples
primary research questions examples
primary research essay
primary research dissertation examples
primary research dissertation structure
is a dissertation a primary source
is a doctoral dissertation a primary source
dissertation primary education
dba dissertation pdf
dissertation primary or secondary source
sample dissertation research questions
sample dissertation chapter 1
dissertation proposal sample pdf
primary data dissertation
dissertation research questions examples
examples of primary research questions
primary research for dissertation
format for dissertation proposal
primary research methodology dissertation example
how to write a primary research paper
sample research statement for promotion to full professor
qualitative research dissertation pdf
dissertation-in-practice
one page dissertation proposal
secondary research dissertation example pdf
undergraduate secondary research dissertation example pdf
what is primary research dissertation
does a dissertation need primary research
primary research study examples
primary research question examples
research proposal discussion example
primary thesis
undergraduate research paper sample pdf
undergraduate research proposal sample
primary v secondary research
dissertation virginia tech
primary sources dissertation
examples of dissertation research questions
1 page research proposal example
1 page research proposal template
1 page research proposal
2 page research proposal
2 research questions
3 paper dissertation
3 research questions examples
3 article dissertation
three-article dissertation examples
three paper dissertation example
dissertation chapter 4 sample
5 chapter dissertation format
5 paragraph research paper example
6 page research paper example
6 page research paper outline
7 page research paper example
8 page research paper exampleassignment help
my assignment help
machine learning assignment help
global assignment help
nursing assignment help
python assignment help
statistics assignment help
programming assignment help
accounting assignment help
deep learning assignment help
coding assignment help
assignment help ai
assignment help app
assignment help australia
assignment help australia reviews
assignment help ads
assignment help app free download
assignment help accounting
assignment help online assignment
assignment benefits for students
benefits of assignment
all assignment help
ai assignment help
architecture assignment help
ai assignment help free
angular assignment help
all assignment help review
autocad assignment help
accounting assignment help online free
academic assignment help
assignment help bangladesh
assignment help blog
assignment help best site
assignment help bd
assignment help brisbane
assignment help bahrain
assignment help bristol
assignment help bradford
assignment help bournemouth
assignment help boston
big data assignment help
btec assignment help
best assignment help websites
budget assignment help
budget friendly assignment help
best programming assignment help
business law assignment help
best assignment help services
business analytics assignment help
best statistics assignment help
assignment help canada
assignment help company
assignment help cheap
assignment help chennai
assignment help center
assignment help canada kijiji
assignment help computer science
assignment help com
assignment help coding
assignment help cipd
cipd assignment help
computer network assignment help
c programming assignment help
college assignment help
chemistry assignment help
cipd assignment help uk
cmi assignment help
canada assignment help
commercial law assignment help
assignment help dubai
assignment help dp
assignment help discord server
database assignment help
diploma assignment help
dbms assignment help
assignment help near me
data visualization assignment help
data structure assignment help
data analysis assignment help
data science assignment help
digi assignment help
digital marketing assignment help
assignment help expert
assignment help excel
assignment help engineering
assignment help me
edu assignment help
what is the importance of assignment
assignment help for students
excel assignment help
expert assignment help
essay assignment help
early childhood education assignment help
elite assignment help
electronics engineering assignment help
electrical engineering assignment help
education assignment help
employer assignment help
assignment help free
assignment help for nursing students
assignment help free online
assignment help from india
assignment help forum
assignment help for international students
assignment help france
assignment help fiverr
assignment help facebook
finance assignment help
free assignment help
financial accounting assignment help
free assignment help websites
fiverr assignment help
forum assignment help
flask assignment help
fluid mechanics assignment help
free assignment help south africa
financial management assignment help
assignment help gumtree
assignment help germany
assignment help gpt
assignment help gurus
assignment help glasgow
assignment help griffith
assignment help gold coast
assignment help group
assignment help geelong
assignment help ghana
great assignment help
global assignment help australia
go assignment help
global assignment help reviews
get assignment help
global assignment help cardiff
gis assignment help
grade assignment help
grasshopper assignment help
assignment help hashtags
assignment help hong kong
assignment help hyderabad
assignment homework help
html assignment help
hnd assignment help
haskell assignment help
hnc assignment help
highgrade assignment help
healthcare assignment help
homework assignment help
how much does assignment help cost
health and social care assignment help
hashtags for assignment help
assignment help india
assignment help ireland
assignment help in uk
assignment help images
assignment help in canada
assignment help in pakistan
assignment help in sri lanka
assignment help in singapore
assignment help in melbourne
assignment help instagram
instant assignment help
india assignment help
ireland assignment help
is my assignment help legit
ignou assignment help
india assignment help reviews
is all assignment help legit
ireland assignment help reviews
image processing assignment help
ilm assignment help
assignment help jobs
assignment help jordan
assignment help johor bahru
assignment help jaipur
assignment help petaling jaya
write smarter assignment help jaipur photos
java assignment help
javascript assignment help
javafx assignment help
java assignment help india
java programming assignment help
james cook university assignment help
jobs at assignment help service
java assignment help review
journalism assignment help
jamovi assignment help
assignment help kenya
assignment help kerala
keras assignment help
assignment help kings
assignment help talk
kaplan assignment help
kijiji assignment help
kingdom assignment help
kaplan business school assignment help
kuwait assignment help
kali linux assignment help
assignment help login
assignment help logo
assignment help law
assignment help sri lanka
my assignment help legit
assignment problem solution
law assignment help
lumion assignment help
last minute assignment help
leadership assignment help
linux assignment help
lisp assignment help
listing assignment help
london assignment help
lab report assignment help
law assignment help india
assignment help massivemark
assignment help malaysia
assignment help melbourne
assignment help math
assignment help mba
marketing assignment help
mongodb assignment help
my assignment help reviews
my assignment help ai pdf summarizer
math assignment help
my assignment help login
matlab assignment help
my assignment help uk
assignment help net
assignment help nepal
assignment help nz reviews
assignment help nigeria
assignment help nursing
nlp assignment help
new assignment help
native assignment help
nmims assignment help
new assignment help australia
need assignment help
new assignment help reviews
nvq assignment help
native assignment help reviews
assignment help online
assignment help online free
assignment help oman
assignment help online uk
assignment help online india
assignment assistance online
assignment answers of nptel
math assignment help online
assignment help jobs online
online assignment help
online assignment help uk
online assignment help australia
opencv assignment help
othm assignment help
online assignment help jobs
organic chemistry assignment help
online tafe assignment help
online mba assignment help
ocaml assignment help
assignment help poster
assignment help pictures
assignment help price
assignment help posts
assignment help profile
assignment help pakistan reviews
php assignment help
power bi assignment help
pyspark assignment help
punjab assignment help
physics assignment help
pgce assignment help
personal finance assignment help
premium assignment help
assignment help qatar
assignment help quora
assignment help quotes
assignment help queensland
assignment quality help
assignment question help
statistics assignment help quora
accounting assignment help quora
engineering assignment help quora
management assignment help quora
quick assignment help
quantity surveying assignment help
qqi assignment help
qut assignment help
quality assignment help
quantitative analysis assignment help
qatar assignment help
qgis assignment help
seeking help in your community assignment quizlet
assignment help reddit
assignment help reviews
assignment help russia
assignment help rmit
assignment help romania
uk assignment help reviews
r programming assignment help
react native assignment help
r studio assignment help
rapid assignment help
reddit assignment help
rmit assignment help
revit assignment help
react js assignment help
research assignment help
racket assignment help
assignment help services
assignment help singapore
assignment help services uk
assignment help sydney
assignment help sites
assignment help services india
assignment help south africa reviews
assignment help south africa
assignment help services pictures
sql assignment help
student assignment help
singapore assignment help
solidworks assignment help
spss assignment help
software engineering assignment help
singapore assignment help review
student assignment help uk
singapore assignment help reddit
assignment help telegram groups
assignment help in the uk
the assignment help
total assignment help
tableau assignment help
tkinter assignment help
tefl assignment help
tort law assignment help
taxation law assignment help
treat assignment help
top assignment help websites
taxation assignment help
assignment help uk
assignment help uae
assignment help uk price
assignment help uts
assignment help uk free
assignment help university
assignment help uk review
assignment help uk cheap
assignment help uae reviews
assignment help unisa
uk assignment help
university assignment help
urgent assignment help
uae assignment help
university assignment help free
uts assignment help
unisa assignment help
university assignment help uk
uk assignment help whatsapp group
assignment help vancouver
value assignment help
verilog assignment help
vlsi assignment help
vhdl assignment help
vba assignment help
visual basic assignment help
how does random assignment help internal validity
cds view search help assignment
assignment help websites
assignment help websites free
assignment help whatsapp group
assignment help website template
assignment help winchester
assignment help writing
assignment help writer
assignment help work
assignment writing help in dubai
assignment writing help in australia
writing assignment help
which website is best for assignment help
websites for assignment help
what does random assignment help with
web development assignment help
webgl assignment help
wgu assignment help
what is assignment help
web designing assignment help
where can i get assignment help
xero assignment help
xero assignment help in australia
assignment recommendation examples
assignment advantages and disadvantages
why assignment is important
x-assist
x4 assign subordinate
x4 assign builder
assignment help new york
assignment 04.01 help your friends
assignment 05.05 can you help me
help your assignment
my assignment help essay typer
my assignment help reviews complaints
my assignment help reddit
my assignment helper
my assignment help app
assignment help zone
assignment help zambia
assignment help new zealand
zoology assignment help
online assignment help new zealand
admx help site to zone assignment list
new zealand assignment help
zoho assist help
a to z assignment
what does assignment number mean
minimum assignment problem
is assignment help legal
help 0-3
need help with assignment
assignment help 11
hr nt assignment help 123 gmail com
no 1 assignment help
com1502 assignment 1 answers
the assignment 1
free assignment help online
homework assignment help online
the assignment part 11
1.3 assignment readiness assessment
assignment 2 answers
247 assignment help
assignment 2r
24 hours assignment help
nmims assignment help 2023
btec level 2 assignment help
ignou helpline number delhi 2 for assignment
af8 assignment 2 help
assignment 2
help for assignment
2-1 assignment project outline
assignment help 360
3co03 assignment help
3co04 assignment help
cipd assignment help level 3
assignment 3 project stem
assignment 3 conflict management
3ds max assignment help
3.8 t assignment help wanted project
cache level 3 assignment help
cipd level 3 assignment help
certificate 3 childcare assignment help
counselling level 3 assignment help
btec level 3 assignment help
assignment help 4 me
assignment help 4 me reviews
assignment help for free
assignment help for me
assignment help for nursing
assignment help for students free
assignment help for early childhood education
4p of marketing assignment help
cert 4 training and assessment assignment help
sus1501 assignment 4 answers
four assignments
4-h essay
lesson 4 helping constituents
lesson 4 assignment
4a assignment
cipd assignment help 5co01
cipd assignment help 5co03
cipd assignment help 5hr03
cipd assignment help 5hr01
cipd assignment help 5co02
cipd assignment help 5hr02
assignment 5 answers
5hr03 assignment help
5os01 assignment help
5hr02 assignment help
5co01 assignment help
5co02 assignment help
5hr01 assignment help
5hr03 cipd assignment help
5c002 assignment help
assignment 6 answers
assignment or assignments
assignment problem example
assignment 6r
assignment 6s
assignment 6 social health
assignment 6 reflection
assignment 6 business finance
6-2 assignment personal development plan
chapter 6 assignment
assignment help 24 7
an assignment problem can be solved by
assignment 7r
assignment 7s
assignment hotline
assignment 7 game wheel
cipd level 7 assignment help
24 7 assignment help
cipd level 7 assignment help uk
helper task list
lesson 7 homework helper
7shifts help
assignment 8s
88 assignments for development in place
assignment 8r
8-1 assignment client results
assignment 8 personal organizer answers
9/11 assignment for high school students
unit 9 assignment assignment help in uk australia canada and usa
assignment help uk
assignment help in canada
usa assignment
immigration assignment
i assisted
language assistance plan
assignment help in uk
assignment in uk
uk assignment help
quill assignment
my assignment helper
my assistance guru
my assignment
assignment 2
assignment 3
assignment 4a
english 4 assignments
5th grade english assignments
6th grade english assignments
7th grade english assignments
unit 7 assignment in the news
8th grade english assignments academic writers in uk australia canada and usa
academic writers uk
academic writers bay
academic authors
canadian english literature
english writers on america
canada authors
british academic writers
do authors go to college
do authors use grammarly
do all authors have english degrees
do writers go to college
do writers use grammarly
english academic writing
uk academic writing
english academic writing course
famous authors from canada
academic writing gcu
great american writer
g author
is academic writer free
k author
uk academic writers
academic writing university
literary academic
n authors
o authors
uk academic publishers
q authors
authors from quebec
canada writer
t authors
u writing
university for authors
writers at york
young writers usa books
z authors
academic english 1
british authors early 20th century
british authors 20th century
british authors 21st century
british authors 21th century
academic writing 5th edition
5 american authors
academic writing books
academic publishers canada assignment and dissertation help
dissertation assistance
help writing a dissertation
assignment and dissertation
dissertation help services
how to write an assignment in university
how to write an assignment for university sample
an assignment of personal services is
ask assignment help
singapore assignment help best essay and dissertation writers reviews
difference between assignment and dissertation
how to write a dissertation proposal
how to write a dissertation plan
how to write an assignment proposal
is doing a dissertation worth it
dissertation assignment help
assignment b.a
c assignment statement
c programming assignment help
cs assignment help
discussion assignment
discussion assignment example
dissertation and defense
how to write a dissertation conclusion
dissertation and theses database
dissertations and theses from start to finish pdf
fafsa assignment
dissertations and theses from start to finish
for assignment
graduate assignment help
thesis assignment
how to write an assignment harvard style
how to write an assignment using harvard referencing
i have an assignment due tomorrow
dissertation assignment
journal assignment
dissertation-in-practice
key assignment draft
dissertation assumptions
assignment k
literature review assignment instructions
mississippi state university thesis and dissertation
major assignment
on an assignment
dissertation help
how to write a dissertation problem statement
phd dissertation assistance
problem statement assignment
problem statement for dissertation examples
discussion question assignment
questions to ask during a dissertation defense
questions for a dissertation defense
rules of assignment problem
r studio assignment help
research assignments
submission assignment
thesis assistance
thesis and dissertation utrgv
university assignment format
understanding an assignment
university assignment help
universal assignment
vhl assignment answers
benefits of assignment
benefits of doing a dissertation
dissertation help writing
written assignment
dissertation assumptions examples
context and thesis
x a b y thesis
your assignment
your dissertation
a to z assignment
03.05 establishing a line of reasoning
dissertation chapter 1 example
1-3 assignment project prep
2-5 assignment importance of analysis
2-5 assignment writing notes
2-1 assignment making difficult decisions using data
3 article dissertation
3 paper dissertation
three essay dissertation
three-article dissertation examples
assignment 3
4-3 assignment identifying your thesis statement
chapter 4 and 5 dissertation
dissertation chapter 4 example
4-1 discussion humanities and other disciplines
5 chapter dissertation format
5 chapter dissertation
5-2 assignment first draft of critical analysis essay
6-1 discussion supporting a thesis statement
assignment 6 discharge and conclusion
6-1 discussion the impact of the humanities
assignment 6 discharge and conclusion delegation
assignment 6 discharge and conclusion shadow health
dissertation apa 7 format
dissertation headings apa 7th edition
dissertation format apa 7th edition
dissertation apa 7th edition
dissertation apa 7
88 assignments for development in place
8-1 discussion implementation and maintenance
8-1 discussion challenges and recommendations
assignment 8s
9 thesis
unit 9 assignment
95 theses assignment
#academicwriting #assignmenthelpuk #england #edinburgh #london #coventry #sunderland #leeds #southampton #oxfordshire #solent #greenwich #essay #essaywriting #reportwriting #dissertation #researchmethods #managementstudies #studyinuk #academiareunido Academia Reunido Website: https://academiareunido.com/online-ervices/ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/academiareunido/ Whatsapp: +447541759335 #AssignmentHelp #DissertationHelp #AcademicSupport #StudentSuccess #WritingAssistance #EssayHelp #ResearchAssistance #CollegeSupport #UniversityWriting #StudyTips #HigherEd #EducationHelp #GradSchool #ScholarshipSuccess #AcademicWriting #StudySmart #StudentLife #Students
